TV Home Forum

BBC HD

Issues and programmes (March 2010)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
DV
DVB Cornwall
Interesting concept ...

BBC HD are offering thirty programmes, from which they will show ten over Easter, Viewers can pick any three from the offered choice.

Voting closes on Friday 19th March

BBC HD Easter
Last edited by DVB Cornwall on 25 September 2010 11:42pm
DE
derek500
Most of those have been shown ad infinitum already!! If I had a pound for every showing of that Joanna Lumley Northern Lights programme, I'd be a rich man!!
Last edited by derek500 on 7 March 2010 8:49pm
NG
noggin Founding member
Most of those have been shown ad infinitum already!! If I had a pounfd for every showing of that Joanna Lumley Norther Lights programme, I'd be a rich man!!


Though it is a brilliant programme - and stands repeated viewing.
BR
Brekkie
Was this list published before or after Kristian Digby died considering they've chosen an episode of Hole in the Wall featuring him?

And secondly, why on earth is money wasted making Hole in the Wall in HD? Or SD come to that matter!
PE
Pete Founding member
Presumably because its shot in the new HD studio at Pacific Quay.

One thing I've noticed with the BBC is they have experimented with many more genres in HD rather than big showbiz and big documentries. Even trashy nonsense like Doctors gives them experience in filming simple soaps in HD, a dry run for EastEnders perhaps.
DV
DVB Cornwall
I hope that Eastenders doesn't go HD. The problem of a fixed point on BBC HD nightly for it would be difficult, if not insurmountable during key events. If (and I stress if) BBC gets a second HD channel, maybe, but now it's a non starter.
PE
Pete Founding member
Indeed that is a major flaw with the whole BBC HD concept, and with Freeview HD.
DJ
DJGM

I hope that Eastenders doesn't go HD. The problem of a fixed point on BBC HD nightly for it
would be difficult, if not insurmountable during key events. If (and I stress if) BBC gets a
second HD channel, maybe, but now it's a non starter.


I think a second BBC HD channel would be pointless. In the not too distant future, all of the BBC's HD content would
be broadcast on their main channels, so eventually, there would be no need for any standalone BBC HD channels.
AS
Asa Admin
DJGM posted:
I think a second BBC HD channel would be pointless. In the not too distant future, all of the BBC's HD content would
be broadcast on their main channels, so eventually, there would be no need for any standalone BBC HD channels.

Makes you wonder at what point it will be viable for BBC One and Two to have HD versions - I'd assume the Beeb already have a percentage in mind it must reach before launching them.

And sorry to sidetrack the thread but does anyone know what the situation is with BBC HD in Australia? Last time I looked they were still using the original idents but now the URL redirects to http://www.uktv.com.au/hd/ with some hybrid logo.

Cheers, Asa
DV
DVB Cornwall
Bearing in mind the latest 'situation' I can't see the BBC getting HD2 for several years, if at all.

unfortunately,
NW
nwtv2003
I don't watch BBC HD simply because I don't have any HD receiving equipment (except an HD ready TV), but as an experimental thing I can understand, but for a broadcaster like the BBC, I would expect BBC1 and BBC2 to be in HD really, for the amount of channels that are in HD, I am surprised there's only one from the BBC. They could model on the 4HD service and upscale anything else that isn't HD. I guess the flaw would be anything from the Kids channels really.

But I guess the good thing about the BBC to have one HD channel is that it leaves room for ITV, Channel 4 and Five to all have an HD service on DTT.
NG
noggin Founding member
Even trashy nonsense like Doctors gives them experience in filming simple soaps in HD, a dry run for EastEnders perhaps.


Not really a good exercise for EastEnders - which is multi-camera and studio-based - but not bad for Holby and Casualty which are more single-camera and shot a bit more like Doctors (though Doctors has quite a lot of location stuff)

But I take your main point about BBC HD funding multiple-genres.

These days I think the BBC assume that if they've spent the money upgrading your studio and/or post-production and location shooting infrastructure then you have to have a good reason for NOT shooting HD.

Newer posts