TV Home Forum

BBC director general Tony Hall warns of threat to British TV

(November 2017)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
:-(
A former member
If the ident are anything judgement were already half way there:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-41843485

Quote:

Favourite British TV shows like Strictly Come Dancing and Broadchurch could be under threat due to a funding shortfall, the BBC is warning.
The rise of services like Netflix and Amazon could mean British content faces "an uncertain future", director general Tony Hall will say in a speech later.
There could be a funding shortfall of £500m over the next 10 years, according to new research.
Lord Hall is to call for a "new golden age for British production".
"The BBC has always shown a great ability to adapt to new challenges and make them opportunities," he will say.
'Face reality'
Speaking in Liverpool, he will say if there is an immediate response to the issue, then the future of British content could be protected.
He calls the figures on funding, from consultants Mediatique and published by the BBC, "worrying".
"We have to face the reality that the British content we value and rely upon is under serious threat."
Lord Hall will add that global services like Netflix, Amazon and Apple are not likely to make up the funding shortfall.
Tony Hall
Image caption
Lord Hall is to say the BBC should remain a 'bastion of brilliant British content'
"The reality is that their investment decisions are likely to focus increasingly on a narrow range of very expensive, very high-end content - big bankers that they can rely on to have international appeal and attract large, global audiences.
"Even the most generous calculations suggest they are barely likely to make up half of the £500m British content gap over the decade ahead. And a more realistic forecast points to substantially less."
'Dramatic change'
The top five shows in the UK this year so far have all been British - the One Love Manchester concert, Broadchurch, Britain's Got Talent, Sherlock and Strictly.
Lord Hall will say that the BBC "should remain a guardian of UK production", and a "bastion of brilliant British content".

"But to achieve this, we have to recognise that the environment around the BBC has changed dramatically, and we must change in response," he will say.

"In the UK we often think of the BBC as a big player, but today the media market is truly global.
"And in that vast solar system, we are tiny compared to the huge gas giants of the US. And every day they're getting bigger."

While about 83% of independent production companies in the UK were British or European-owned 10 years ago, today that figure is less than 40% - the rest are owned by US multinationals.
WH
Whataday Founding member
Obviously these are cherry picked quotes from his speech but seriously, what a load of old guff.

The amount of British produced content (or content produced by British companies) for international television has never been higher than any point in our history.

The implication is that the likes of Netflix/Amazon etc do not value British programming and would happily pump us full of imports, when we have seen anything but that occur.

What I think he's actually saying is "we're relying less on the BBC for high quality content", and I can't really see that as a cause for complaint.
bkman1990, Brekkie and ToasterMan gave kudos
HC
Hatton Cross
In other words..
"hey Netflix and Amazon, come and talk to BBC Studios for some drama formats, and let's make a derivative 10 part gritty crime serial with a £15 million per episode budget together.
Good for you, good for BBC Studios"
JA
JAS84
Strange that they cited Broadchurch, when that's NOT a BBC show...
WH
Whataday Founding member
I think he's just taking it as read that ITV will get swallowed up by some American giant and therefore any notion that they'll be able to spend money on British drama is out the window.

As I said, guff.
IS
Inspector Sands
I think he's just taking it as read that ITV will get swallowed up by some American giant and therefore any notion that they'll be able to spend money on British drama is out the window.

Surely it's more about the production companies? If less than 40% of them aren't British or even European owned, then it's irrelevant who owns ITV. The content is increasingly foreign owned
JO
Joe
JAS84 posted:
Strange that they cited Broadchurch, when that's NOT a BBC show...

Why..?
WH
Whataday Founding member
I think he's just taking it as read that ITV will get swallowed up by some American giant and therefore any notion that they'll be able to spend money on British drama is out the window.

Surely it's more about the production companies? If less than 40% of them aren't British or even European owned, then it's irrelevant who owns ITV. The content is increasingly foreign owned


But that doesn't put British made content at risk does it? That's what he's saying. If 21st Century Fox buys ITV Studios, Coronation Street isn't suddenly going to become Michigan Avenue.
IS
Inspector Sands

But that doesn't put British made content at risk does it? That's what he's saying. If 21st Century Fox buys ITV Studios, Coronation Street isn't suddenly going to become Michigan Avenue.

No of course not, but if a programme is made by a foreign production company who's pulling the strings and making the decisions, where is the intellectual property owned and more importantly where are the profits going?

Forget ITV, look at the other 60%. Theres been a massive amount of takeovers and consolidation in the TV production industry over the past few years. Is it a good thing to have it all ending up in American hands?

The likes of Amazon and Netflix are another matter, the threat to British content is real. As he says they have big pockets and will spend on content that has international appeal
WH
Whataday Founding member

But that doesn't put British made content at risk does it? That's what he's saying. If 21st Century Fox buys ITV Studios, Coronation Street isn't suddenly going to become Michigan Avenue.

No of course not, but if a programme is made by a foreign production company who's pulling the strings and making the decisions, where is the intellectual property owned and more importantly where are the profits going?


That doesn't really have any bearing on the content though does it? He's not really talking about the business side of it, he's saying it will have an effect on content. The idea that US giants would swoop in, asset strip a company and leave it churning out 'foreign muck' is such a blinkered and dated opinion to have.

The British TV industry is one of the strongest in the world and if any international company buys into it, they're doing it because they want to be a part of it, not because they want to close down their offices and run things from a small office in 30 Rock.

Look at FremantleMedia, one of the biggest production companies in the world, huge productions across the globe. German owned, headquartered in London.

He may feel that the BBC is small fry on a global scale, but he is wrong to bundle the whole industry in with that and he's absolutely understating how strong British production is.
IS
Inspector Sands
But his argument is that the money to commission programmes is coming from the American big boys with deep pockets because the gap in funding is increasing. So the now big transatlantic 'indies' that have traditionally made British content for British TV are going to be increasingly making international content for them instead. The broadcasters here have less money and broadcasting is supposedly on the way out.

A foreign owned company will always have more of an international outlook than a home grown one. And the bigger the company the more they'll follow the money. These aren't fledgling little indies in Fitzrovia who are grateful for a 6 part documentary commission on channel 4, they're small parts of big multinationals

Incidently he mentions the proportion of production that is British/European owned, presumably that is because they are counted together now for quota purposes? I wonder how that will change post Brexit?
Last edited by Inspector Sands on 3 November 2017 10:01am
WH
Whataday Founding member
I'm reminded of the furore over the launch of Sky, and the threat that in a few years time we'd be watching virtually nothing but American imports because the British TV industry was too small to survive in a multi-channel world. Fast forward 20 odd years and some of the highest rating shows on AMERICAN TV have been produced by British based companies.

Newer posts