The Newsroom

The Weather Forecast Thread

> 'Nice' weather girls... >More wet weather set for UK (February 2005)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
SP
Sput
Nick Harvey posted:
dodrade posted:
Believe me there are people stupid enough to make that mistake, including many elderly people.

You can stuff that comment where the sun don't shine, young 'un!


Wouldn't that be the new maps?
MO
Moz
Thinking about it, I wish now they've gone for this system, they should bin the symbols altogether. The pictures kindly posted on the last page are far more effective than the old symbols, and on the maps the shading should be used.

Consider this map...

http://www.bbc.co.uk/weather/charts/uk/uk_summary_05051912.jpg

I live in Wrexham, NE Wales (just to the left of the '17' on the map). What's my weather? No idea! Could be rainy or sunny, we're halfway between two symbols.

If it were shaded as on the TV forecast, I'd know.

BIN THE OLD SYMBOLS FOR EVER!
GM
nodnirG kraM

Which is all very well, and no matter how lovely it is flying over a badly-antialiased map of Britain waiting for your part of the country to appear, I can't help but think that it was rather easier before: you knew exactly where the bit you live is on the map and simply look for the nearest symbol to work out what the weather will be like. Symbols such as a cloud a sun or a big jagged lightning bolt. Clear as day. Or a cloudless sky.

Now I've not only got to either wait patiently for my bit of the country to appear, or search over the map, try and work out just where the rain border ends and decide whether I'm in a light brown or a dark brown bit in order to work out if it'll be cloudy or not.


Yes the graphics are fantastically well done and the whole concept is very clever. But it's a little TOO clever. They've gone that bit too far. Weather bulletins shouldn't be like a Mensa exam question.
SE
Square Eyes Founding member
Whats with only having place names on the coastal fringes on the national forecast ? That fiercely territorial midlands lot won't be very happy with that.
MA
marksi
Helen Young has just completed the 1.30 forecast without mentioning wind once.

Edit: Angie had lots of wind on Newsline.
SE
Square Eyes Founding member
marksi posted:
Helen Young has just completed the 1.30 forecast without mentioning wind once.


Paul Hudson had a lot of wind at lunchtime. Shocked
WI
william Founding member
Square Eyes posted:
Whats with only having place names on the coastal fringes on the national forecast ? That fiercely territorial midlands lot won't be very happy with that.


There's now not enough room for the temperatures otherwise, what with the map being smaller etc. ...
WI
william Founding member
Hmm, South East Today has just underrun by about 30 seconds, probably the longest version of the bed I've ever heard.

The map definitely is a *lot* smaller, and we only get about half the place names we used to. The wind was mentioned 2 or 3 times but no isobars.
RW
Robert Williams Founding member
marksi posted:
Helen Young has just completed the 1.30 forecast without mentioning wind once.

Plenty of wind on the BBC London weather (at least I think that's what all those white bits mean).

http://www.tvradiobits.co.uk/Weather5.jpg
KA
Katherine Founding member
william posted:
Square Eyes posted:
Whats with only having place names on the coastal fringes on the national forecast ? That fiercely territorial midlands lot won't be very happy with that.


There's now not enough room for the temperatures otherwise, what with the map being smaller etc. ...

I'm won over!!!! I love them!
MN
MarkN Founding member
nodnirG kraM posted:
Which is all very well, and no matter how lovely it is flying over a badly-antialiased map of Britain waiting for your part of the country to appear


At least you don't live in Lerwick - I think the BBC forgot about the people on the Shetland Isles when they implemented the new system!
WI
william Founding member
Robert Williams posted:
marksi posted:
Helen Young has just completed the 1.30 forecast without mentioning wind once.

Plenty of wind on the BBC London weather (at least I think that's what all those white bits mean).

http://www.tvradiobits.co.uk/Weather5.jpg


Compare and contrast that with this:

http://www.wturrell.co.uk/misc/bbc-weather-wind-old.jpg

Now, which is clearer?

Newer posts