The Newsroom

Sue Lawley quits Deser Island Discs

Could she return to news? (April 2006)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
MO
Moz
Broadcaster Sue Lawley is stepping down as presenter of BBC Radio 4's Desert Island Discs after 18 years.

I think she was an excellent newsreader in her day and would love to see her return to some sort of news programme, maybe something on News 24.
BN
Breakfast News
Oh yes she was fab, some sort of weekend news chat show on News 24? She'd be brilliant - she quit too early IMO - she was the complete professional.
JO
johnnybegood
Doubt she's exactly what News 24 needs, though.

She is suited to radio and current affairs IMHO and rolling news would not necessarily be her forte!

She could do the World at One or similar on Radio 4 or even something like a consumerism programme..

She's just a little old school for BBC TV News IMHO and they seem to be drifting away from this...
TI
tightrope78
How about returning to her roots and presenting the new 'Nationwide'? Wink
MO
Moz
johnnybegood posted:
rolling news would not necessarily be her forte!

You don't remember her when she was in news then?

I can remember her as totally unflappable, and very good at thinking on her feet. Two things spring to mind - the occasion when she was presenting the Six when it was 'rather invaded', and also when she was presenting some sort of 'your BBC' programme with the BBC Chair & DG where viewers phoned in. While they were on air the Kegworth Air Crash happened and she handed over to the newsroom. I can remember her handling this major incident professionally, carrying on with the debate but also keeping in touch with the news and giving regular updates.

Rolling news would come naturally to her!
JW
JamesWorldNews
Rolling news would be a walk in the park for the Lady. Let's not forget, she was also one of the great interrogators of her time too - ranked alongside Sir Robin Day and Brain Walden as the other mainstays of the era.

In fact, there was a rumour that she (Lawley) gave the then PM Thatcher such a hard time during one live tv interview on Nationwide, that Thatcher refused ever to be interviewed by her again.

It would be great to see Sue back on TV News. In fact, although I also rate the current presenter exceptionally highly, I think Sue would be good on "The World" on BBC World.

Better still, why not get her onto WNT and get rid of James Rubin?
TV
archiveTV
BBC WORLD posted:
Rolling news would be a walk in the park for the Lady. Let's not forget, she was also one of the great interrogators of her time too - ranked alongside Sir Robin Day and Brain Walden as the other mainstays of the era.

In fact, there was a rumour that she (Lawley) gave the then PM Thatcher such a hard time during one live tv interview on Nationwide, that Thatcher refused ever to be interviewed by her again.

It would be great to see Sue back on TV News. In fact, although I also rate the current presenter exceptionally highly, I think Sue would be good on "The World" on BBC World.

Better still, why not get her onto WNT and get rid of James Rubin?


That was the famous incident in 1983 when Nationwide allowed viewers to directly question the party leaders.

From Wikipedia
Diana Gould, a geography teacher from Cirencester, persistently challenged Margaret Thatcher about her ordering of the sinking of the General Belgrano when it was sailing away from the Falklands. Mrs Thatcher either made a verbal slip or misremembered the history and denied that the Belgrano had been sailing away, and Diana Gould therefore appeared better informed. When Mrs Thatcher asked her whether she accepted that the Belgrano had been a danger to British shipping when it was sunk, Mrs Gould told her that she did not. Thatcher then proclaimed that "I think it could only be in Britain that a British Prime Minister could be asked why she took action to protect our ships against an enemy ship that was a danger to our shipping", and was extremely angry about the BBC for allowing the question (Cockerell, 1988:238). Thatcher's husband Denis lashed out at the producer of the show in the entertainment suite, saying that his wife had been "stitched up by bloody BBC poofs and Trots."

Sue Lawley was the moderator of the interview so was associated with the pinko BBC by Thatcher

Newer posts