The Newsroom

UK General Election

Thurs 8th June 2017 - **Presentation related discussion only** (April 2017)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
:-(
A former member
I see BBC Scotland is copying STV way of doing the debates. This may be a new thing for UK voters but these types of debates having been going on for years in Scotland and basally Question time.
CR
Critique
Is there any particular reasoning behind Huw Edwards being in Edinburgh and lleading coverage for the News Channel of tonight's Scottish Leaders' Debate? When I saw it I assumed it was part of a BBC One programme perhaps only for viewers in Scotland previewing the debate, but he seems to be there just to do bits for the NC, with Clive Myrie presenting the teatime BBC One bulletin (which is slightly odd in itself, as he seems to split the evening NC shift with Martine Croxall, who is on air tonight).
AN
Andrew Founding member
Huw presented quite a chunk of the teatime bulletin from Edinburgh
AS
AlexS
3"]Is there any particular reasoning behind Huw Edwards being in Edinburgh and lleading coverage for the News Channel of tonight's Scottish Leaders' Debate? When I saw it I assumed it was part of a BBC One programme perhaps only for viewers in Scotland previewing the debate, but he seems to be there just to do bits for the NC, with Clive Myrie presenting the teatime BBC One bulletin (which is slightly odd in itself, as he seems to split the evening NC shift with Martine Croxall, who is on air tonight).

Clive often (supposedly 1 in 3 but in reality nearer to 1 in 2) presents the teatime and late BBC1 bulletins on Sundays, but never presents the evening NC shift on Sundays.
It wouldn't surprise me if Huw being the presenter in Edinburgh is no more than him being the only relatively senior presenter that was willing and available to cover it rather than a conscious decision to send the flagship anchor.
:-(
A former member
If were talking about the two weekend Bullitins around 18.30 and 22.00 then I would say I would push it out further for Clive, as its the two woman who appear more often on those slots.
:-(
A former member
From Tonight Scottish Debate:

From TV LIVE
*
*

Pres room, which is STV idea:
*

There now sitting down..
*
Look at the Angry
*

Hopeful TV LIVE will have corvage of the six or Ten remaining Debates * (It could will be more since NI is not listed, nor is BBC Wales..)
BR
Brekkie
Quite odd really to have a general election debate where those debating are elected to offices other than Westminster.
SW
Steve Williams
Quite odd really to have a general election debate where those debating are elected to offices other than Westminster.


Leanne Wood, Nicola Sturgeon and Paul Nuttall were all in the leader's debate last week, none of whom have ever held a Westminster seat.
BA
bilky asko
It was nice to see the full floorplan of the studio. I hadn't realised that the CSO area took up almost a third of the space.


It was a matter of blink and you'll miss it. Wink


What do they fill the CSO with for the standard wide shots? For example when they're discussing something at the desk and cut to a slow moving wide shot.


Do what they did last time - make sure most of the shots avoid the green area, which isn't too difficult, as it only takes up a quarter of the potential shots. Otherwise, leave in the last CG used by Jeremy Vine.
SP
Steve in Pudsey
Don't the Vine bits come via a separate gallery? So it's not not difficult for the main mixer to be set up to key just black in place of the green, or a fake screen?
ST
Stuart
Just watching the first of the Andrew Neil Interviews on BBC One. What location are they using for this?

http://i66.tinypic.com/2ipxk1.jpg
Last edited by Stuart on 22 May 2017 7:12pm
DF
DrewF
My guess would be Westminster Tower.

Newer posts