CA
First election night ever Sky have been ahead of the BBC with results, so a big win. Graphics easily the best. I don't understand why others don't do the ticker tape.
But didn't like the rest of it
First, the quality of Sky guests and analysis of the results was second rate for the first few hours. After the exit poll BBC had McDonnell and Fallon; ITV we know had Osborne/Balls. Sky had Ken Loach and Craig Oliver... and they just didn't seem to have that many guests booked (vs itv or BBC)
Boulton alone at a massive desk with Lewis and Ed confusingly seated behind him didn't work
And seriously they need to get over this obsession about showing every live count they can. Endless coverage of counts is really not illuminating. I get that it's a technical achievement, but it's stood in the way of analysis on a night when analysis was needed.
I would much rather have had Boulton, Ridge, Faisal Islam and Lewis Goodall, Michael Thrasher with some political commentators around the table and Ed at the wall.
It was fast and Lewis Goodall was good... but there was too much counting and not enough analysis. Poor, all in all.
But didn't like the rest of it
First, the quality of Sky guests and analysis of the results was second rate for the first few hours. After the exit poll BBC had McDonnell and Fallon; ITV we know had Osborne/Balls. Sky had Ken Loach and Craig Oliver... and they just didn't seem to have that many guests booked (vs itv or BBC)
Boulton alone at a massive desk with Lewis and Ed confusingly seated behind him didn't work
And seriously they need to get over this obsession about showing every live count they can. Endless coverage of counts is really not illuminating. I get that it's a technical achievement, but it's stood in the way of analysis on a night when analysis was needed.
I would much rather have had Boulton, Ridge, Faisal Islam and Lewis Goodall, Michael Thrasher with some political commentators around the table and Ed at the wall.
It was fast and Lewis Goodall was good... but there was too much counting and not enough analysis. Poor, all in all.