The Newsroom

Sky News: Presentation Discussion

(May 2010)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
NE
Newsroom
Boulton said earlier that Brown hadn't got the qualities for a PM and said that he'll be quickly forgotten.

Adding salt to the wounds!


Boulton is a scandal of late. He's seriously losing his grip on his position, one I believe is becoming more and more untenable.

Some of the papers are reporting that OFCOM have received hundreds of complaints over his spat with Campbell. Exact figures will be announced today. I do hope Boulton is put out to pastures, enough is enough. Time for Sky to look at breaking new talent.
BR
Brekkie
I don't how viable it would be but would be better to provide looped news coverage through the Sky Anytime service, which could then play out full screen and from beginning to end when you selected it. I doubt though the Sky+ boxes could handle material being added ad-hoc though throughout the day.

Must say though for all that we moan about Sky News their Sky Text service is superb and provided decent coverage of the election results (though only winners, not full results).
GI
gillw72
Interesting article in the New Statesman where Adam defends Sky' simpartiality and also hints that HD rehearsals didn't go well...

http://www.newstatesman.com/uk-politics/2010/05/sky-news-cameron-election
NG
noggin Founding member
Boulton said earlier that Brown hadn't got the qualities for a PM and said that he'll be quickly forgotten.

Adding salt to the wounds!


Boulton is a scandal of late. He's seriously losing his grip on his position, one I believe is becoming more and more untenable.

Some of the papers are reporting that OFCOM have received hundreds of complaints over his spat with Campbell. Exact figures will be announced today. I do hope Boulton is put out to pastures, enough is enough. Time for Sky to look at breaking new talent.


There is an argument that Ofcom complaints are increasingly being driven by Twitter / Facebook etc. (and in some cases The Daily Mail etc.). Whether this is a good thing - as more people are discovering material that they think is unacceptable and making their opinions known to the regulators - or a bad thing as more and more people jump on a bandwagon and are "offended second-hand" is up for discussion.

I think my issue with Boulton - which I've had for years - is that he appears so smug and self-important, and as he's reportedly the best paid TV journalist in the UK (AIUI the BBC couldn't afford him even if they wanted him...) this presumably fuels this arrogant attitude. He thinks he's brilliant. People tell him he's brilliant. He gets some great stories. However he's not a great presenter, and he's not super human...

All it takes is lack of sleep / lack of food (wonder if he had low blood-sugar during the Campbell spat - rather than being drunk as others have suggested) and the veneer cracks and reveals that he's not as good as he thinks he is...

I have a similar issue with Kay Burley. She thinks she's great. Sky must continuously tell her she's great. She's a polished, if very mannered, Autocue-reader. However she's very limited in her interviewing skills - and appears to think she can be Jeremy Paxman. She can't - she's simply not bright enough... (And her faux sincerity on the softer interviews is truly nauseating)

How she survived nearly throttling the PA photographer I don't know - but that was off-screen.

What was worse was, on-screen, asking the wife of the Ipswich murderer whether she felt her husband would have killed women if they'd had a better sex life. That was probably one of the most appalling pieces of tabloid TV I've seen ever in the UK. Jaw dropping on so many levels. (Editorially though - I think it was pre-recorded - so you can't JUST blame Kay Burley for that - others approved it too.)

(Her ignorance of Joe Biden's Ash Wednesday mark was less jaw dropping - but again exposed her lack of actual knowledge and substance... That was live...)

On the other hand they both make great fodder for a new series of Newswipe or Screenwipe...
Last edited by noggin on 12 May 2010 11:24am - 2 times in total
RO
roo
Eww eww eww the Breaking News/headline strap needs to go. Eww.
*
BR
Brekkie
It's certainly time for Sky to review his position, but one thing I will say in his favour is although he was in the wrong, it's refreshing nowadays to see someone stand up for themselves rather than rolling over with a grovelling apology the minute somebody suggests they were not acting appropriately. If more had done that a few years back TV wouldn't be in the (nanny)state it's in today.
FO
fodg09
gillw posted:
Interesting article in the New Statesman where Adam defends Sky' simpartiality and also hints that HD rehearsals didn't go well...

http://www.newstatesman.com/uk-politics/2010/05/sky-news-cameron-election


Thanks for that was looking for that article yesterday. He makes some pretty interesting points.
DE
derek500


Some of the papers are reporting that OFCOM have received hundreds of complaints over his spat with Campbell. Exact figures will be announced today.


Only hundreds? After all the leftwing blogs/Facebook/Twitter etc. I wonder how many were received within half hour of the broadcast?

They need to put a time limit on online complaints.

Strange though, that last year these same blogs etc., were berating 'Daily Mail readers' for complaining about 'Sachsgate' after the event, without hearing it live. Now the boot's on the other foot, it's OK.
SE
Square Eyes Founding member
Ofcom complaints as of this morning

Kay Burley - 722
Adam Boulton - 696
GI
ginnyfan
So silly to have these complaints, I don't like Adam's pink tie, maybe I should complain too. Rolling Eyes
GI
gillw72
Ofcom complaints as of this morning

Kay Burley - 722
Adam Boulton - 696


Kay could bump hers up a bit this afternoon. She is back at Abingdon Green and a small crowd is gathering...
FO
fodg09
Another good days ratings for Sky yesterday, behind the BBC as is the case these days but still a strong performance.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2010/may/12/david-cameron-tv-ratings

That all day share of 2.4% is amongst the best in Sky News' history I think.

Newer posts