NG
Not sure what 'Salam Pax – GuardianFilms/Newsnight for BBC Two' is, but purely on an innovation basis, I can't see there's much contest between the ITV News semi-virtual set and C4 Snowmail! Hasn't email been going for decades? The ITV News set is just a tad more innovative than that...
I think Salam Pax was the Iraqi Blogger that Newsnight featured through the reconstruction of Iraq. He films his own reports and they are quite good and I have always found them really interesting. I would like to see him win.
Sounds good (I didn't see it), but in what way was it innovative?
I think the whole concept of blogging - whereby individuals are able to tell their own stories on-line has been an interesting and powerful development over the past few years, and it has driven grass-roots campaigning quite significantly.
In the case of Salam Pax, he was posting his thoughts on life inside Iraq during the conflict, not the political stuff, just the mundanities of living in a war zone. The Guardian picked up on this, and he has been writing similar stuff for them. Annoyingly, I didn't see the Newsnight films (I don't get to see Newsnight that often at the moment) - but if they are as witty and detailed as his online and newspaper articles they will probably have been fascinating.
I think the innovation is getting someone who isn't a TV journalist to produce authored reports, but using the "blog" style - not campaigning as such, just detailing "real life" as they experience it.
Whilst the ITN "Theatre of News" set is technically quite clever - and in some ways innovative (though the technology in use is not new - and so doesn't really count as a technical innovation) - there are still many in the TV community who question its merits artistically.
I think that innovation doesn't just have to be technical - in many ways production innovation (i.e. changing how you editorially cover a story rather than technically) is more difficult because it isn't driven by new, high-tech boxes of kit, it is driven by a desire to tell stories differently, or tell new stories.
noggin
Founding member
Jonathan H posted:
arabian_lawrence posted:
Jonathan H posted:
cat posted:
The innovation category is pretty weak. If the best they can find is C4's Snowmail - a concept that's been going for years - then god help us.
Not sure what 'Salam Pax – GuardianFilms/Newsnight for BBC Two' is, but purely on an innovation basis, I can't see there's much contest between the ITV News semi-virtual set and C4 Snowmail! Hasn't email been going for decades? The ITV News set is just a tad more innovative than that...
I think Salam Pax was the Iraqi Blogger that Newsnight featured through the reconstruction of Iraq. He films his own reports and they are quite good and I have always found them really interesting. I would like to see him win.
Sounds good (I didn't see it), but in what way was it innovative?
I think the whole concept of blogging - whereby individuals are able to tell their own stories on-line has been an interesting and powerful development over the past few years, and it has driven grass-roots campaigning quite significantly.
In the case of Salam Pax, he was posting his thoughts on life inside Iraq during the conflict, not the political stuff, just the mundanities of living in a war zone. The Guardian picked up on this, and he has been writing similar stuff for them. Annoyingly, I didn't see the Newsnight films (I don't get to see Newsnight that often at the moment) - but if they are as witty and detailed as his online and newspaper articles they will probably have been fascinating.
I think the innovation is getting someone who isn't a TV journalist to produce authored reports, but using the "blog" style - not campaigning as such, just detailing "real life" as they experience it.
Whilst the ITN "Theatre of News" set is technically quite clever - and in some ways innovative (though the technology in use is not new - and so doesn't really count as a technical innovation) - there are still many in the TV community who question its merits artistically.
I think that innovation doesn't just have to be technical - in many ways production innovation (i.e. changing how you editorially cover a story rather than technically) is more difficult because it isn't driven by new, high-tech boxes of kit, it is driven by a desire to tell stories differently, or tell new stories.