« Topics
1234...78910
Jock5007 posts since 21 Sep 2019 new member
London London
Oh dear, I’d say the new music hits a bum note!
The new theme for BBC London News is far better.
However, Laura is a great successor to Jackie.
I’m sure she’ll bring her own style of presentation to the programme.
London Lite10,791 posts since 4 Jan 2003
London London
Here was an opportunity to stop Reporting Scotland being a provincial, bland 'local' news programme and instead it's more of the same.

In the same building, they've tried and innovated with The Nine which is on a channel that nobody watches with some excellent journalism and presentation, yet it seems RS is so worried about annoying their older audience that it's business as usual.

This is why STV News at Six market leads.
2
reubz and Jock500 gave kudos
62305823,625 posts since 19 Aug 2005
The main reason for the minor refresh is because Laura miller is now the head presenter. If she is stick doing the same old rubbish from them up stairs it's not going to solve the issues around Reporting scotland,
Last edited by 623058 on 29 October 2019 7:49pm
Mike W4,931 posts since 30 Apr 2006
London London
It's basically a modified version of the 2008 National titles template (maybe with some new shots added in, using said template) and redone in HD?

It's meh, but then it is just a refresh. I'm not sure dropping the map of Scotland (so obviously) was a good move. As others have said they could've gone with something similar to the Nine or completely off the wall but on brand.
Oh it's such a perfect day, I'm glad I spent it with you...
Mr Kite891 posts since 15 Aug 2007
Granada North West Today
I'm disappointed they ditched the familiar tune that's been in place since 1999 for something generic and bland. A nice remix could have been done - but instead it's something that you'd expect to find on some BBC News Channel stand now.

Absolutely - in fact, the Reporting Scotland theme was, in my opinion, one of David Lowe's better creations in 1999. It was certainly my favourite of the regions/nations themes at the time.


I concurr. Always liked the blue too.

Not sure how I feel about ditching the pips entirely. It all feels rather fatigued and tired now; and the original map titles and 'to the point' headlines were always far superior to what has followed. At the same time though, it is pretty well known and associated with the BBC, so we should be wary about throwing it out entirely.

What does contribute to the fatigue is its overuse throughout the news operations. Even in the early years, it felt a bit much insisting that regional politics shows such as North Westminster have a narrow variant on the pips theme. Even Newsround didn't entirely escape it in the look immediately preceding the current one. Some people on here were saying "about time" but I was thinking "oh ffs".

This is why I think we should go back to the future and allow the regional news programmes to do their own thing again; within the boundaries of broad branding parameters. Same with Breakfast and things like BBC Parliament. Reporting Scotland could've been a trailblazer for this approach. Keep the pips for the network news and the news channel. A good back to basics refresh and shorter headlines like back in '99 combined with the narrower remit would give it a new leese of life, I'm sure.
RDJ2,766 posts since 25 Oct 2003
Central (South) Midlands Today
I'm really not sure what they were aiming for here. A re-hash of the News Channel titles taking the focus away from Scotland with a bit of blue chucked in and a bland departure to the familiar theme barely changed in 20 years.

STV leads in Scottish local news as that is what they focus on, especially with the four sub-regions.

BBC Scotland had a good chance here to revitalise its main national news and become a contender, especially with the resources it now has with its channel. But instead they decided to go for the basics and continue to just plod along.
Central News South
January 9th 1989 - December 3rd 2006
3
Owen_ploc, ittrgrey and GMc gave kudos