The Newsroom

Miners Rescue - Chile

"WITH ME, TIM WILLCOX." (October 2010)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
WO
Worzel
Nice to hear Martin Stanford on Sky's coverage, presumably giving Andrew a bit of a break or waiting for Robert Nisbet take over.


About time too!
WO
Worzel
I believe that BBC News have been rolling this Breaking story now for at least 25 hours, longest rolling Breaking story since Michael Jackson's death?
FO
fodg09
Impressive to see Tim Wilcox interviewing the Chilean President.
WO
Worzel
Theres a bit of an exclusive for the BBC that the President of Chile asking to speak to 'BBC Tim' - Tim Willcox. Tim's really done well over the past 24hours!

(I reckon he knows that Tim was nearly always on BBC News 24 doing long shifts - so he renamed the channel!) Wink
CH
Chie
That's the first rescue that's had me a bit emotional. Tim interviewing the president now.
BE
Ben Founding member
I have to say I think Tim Wilcox has done brilliantly, even when presenting with Matt Frei yesterday Tim seemed to have the edge and was better at filling. I'm sure the fact he has been there for a few weeks has helped though.
MI
Michael
This makes interesting reading (it's the Guardian)... http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2010/oct/13/bbc-chile-miners-rescue-bill

Discraceful IMO. The miners story maybe interesting, but that's it - interesting

The G20, Nato, Climate summits are not just interesting, they could affect people and businesses. They could dictate banking regulation, policy in Afghanistan etc. They need to have full coverage IMO. Yet license fee payers money has instead been spent on 'nice to have' extensive coverage from Chile which could have been done with less staff and at less cost (Look at CNNI, just 3 correspondents there and no presenter)


That's a bit of an overreaction IMO. I don't think coverage of the G20 et al will suffer from not having an extra correspondent on the ground. Besides, these summits come around once every few years, there's a lot of talking, not much action, a few protests and a lot of talking heads um and ah for a few days. This miners story is a ONCE IN A LIFETIME extraordinarily interesting, heartwarming, technically astounding, visually and emotionally stunning news event. Saving a few pennies on an air fare and a hotel room elsewhere is hardly going to ruin BBC News' standards. Robert and Nick could easily both go if they stayed in a Travelodge. Not that they would.

And the less said about the Oscars, the better.
MI
Michael
Ben posted:
I have to say I think Tim Wilcox has done brilliantly, even when presenting with Matt Frei yesterday Tim seemed to have the edge and was better at filling. I'm sure the fact he has been there for a few weeks has helped though.


And he habla espanol too!
WP
WillPS
Just saw the TOTH sequence for BBC World News America on the News Channel.
WO
Worzel
Just saw the TOTH sequence for BBC World News America on the News Channel.


I was expecting Matt Frei to do the opener in Spanish to throw everyone. Wink
MA
Markymark
This miners story is a ONCE IN A LIFETIME extraordinarily interesting, heartwarming, technically astounding, visually and emotionally stunning news event.


You're obviously too young to remember the Apollo 13 rescue ?

I'm abroad at the moment, and only have access to CNN; their coverage makes 'The Day Today' look like a subdued critique.
I doubt Sky and BBC are too far behind in crassness ? (if such a word exists)

I agree, it is a technically astounding enterprise, I look forward to a proper non dumbed down documentary on the subject in the near future, because news channel editorial staff have NO appreciation of the effort and skill involved .
MI
Michael
This miners story is a ONCE IN A LIFETIME extraordinarily interesting, heartwarming, technically astounding, visually and emotionally stunning news event.


You're obviously too young to remember the Apollo 13 rescue ?


Yes. Maybe generation would be a better word, although I don't think we'll see something of the like of Apollo 13 or this mining rescue again. Certainly not on the scale.

And BBC isn't being crass at all (I've avoided Sky entirely this time after the Raoul Moat debacle) they've been like everyone else - completely and utterly caught up in the positivity of it all.

Newer posts