The Newsroom

Michael Buerk

Anna Ford hits back (August 2005)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
TV
TVN
No, Moira Stuart has not gone into hiding, he was talking about sexism, and the fact that it has gone too far.

I wholehardedly agree with MBs comments, in this article http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/entertainment/tv_and_radio/4155228.stm

People need to realise that positive discrimination (i.e. choosing a person for a job just because they are in a minority group to fill quotas etc) is just as bad as any discrimination. The only fair way to give a job is to choose the best applicant, even if you do end up having an all white or all male workforce.

If, for example, we take the BBC News, the main anchors are:-
Huw Edwards, Fiona Bruce, Sophie Raworth, George Alagiah, Darren Jordan, Anna Ford, Dermott Murnaghan, Sian Williams, Bill Turnbull and Natasha Kaplinsky.

Precisely half of these are female. Precisely half of these are male. Coincidence? I think not. There are clearly some women who are only in their jobs because they are women, and the BBC thinks they have to be represented in this way, even though there are many other male newsreaders who may be better.

There is also the unspoken rule that a pairing on any bulletin (network or N24) has to be male-female. This is unfair. I happen to *know* that Huw Edwards and Jon Sopel would make an excellent pairing for the six, but this cannot happen because of this rule.

The fact is, positive discrimination is just as bad as discrimination itself, and has to be stopped.

Oh, and Asa: hurry up and get some female mods before the PC Police come for you!!! Laughing
BN
Breakfast News
"Burke, who now works on BBC World.."

What does he do on World?
NH
Nick Harvey Founding member
He must be freelance now, as he starts a series for five next week; can't remember which day, but in the 19:15 slot, after the news.
DO
dodrade
It seems to me there are more female weather presenters on the BBC than men, is this the case?
SH
Showbizguru
Personally,I think the more female BBC newsreaders the better.
Someone has to tidy up the newsroom.
NH
Nick Harvey Founding member
I always thought Huw had a Hoover round during the local news at about half past ten.
NE
Noelfirl
Showbizguru posted:
Personally,I think the more female BBC newsreaders the better.
Someone has to tidy up the newsroom.


Oh look, a pretty feeble attempt at controversial commenting. How fascinating.

Nick Harvey posted:
I always thought Huw had a Hoover round during the local news at about half past ten.


Someone could make my day by posting caps from the Alistair McGowan sketch from back yonder where Huw does such hoovering (amongst other things), during the Six opt-out.
SH
Showbizguru
Someone could make my day by posting caps from the Alistair McGowan sketch from back yonder where Huw does such hoovering (amongst other things), during the Six opt-out.[/quote]

That one scores highly on the sad-ometer too.
AN
All New Johnnyboy
Anyone needing evidence of the female takeover of newsrooms only needs to watch Channel Report.

Correct me if I'm wrong but I don't think there is one journo on it who is male.

The females they have on it, for example, Katherine Spence, are very sexy. Wonder why ugly women can't do the news anymore?
JD
jdtech
All New Johnnyboy posted:
Anyone needing evidence of the female takeover of newsrooms only needs to watch Channel Report.

Correct me if I'm wrong but I don't think there is one journo on it who is male.

The females they have on it, for example, Katherine Spence, are very sexy. Wonder why ugly women can't do the news anymore?


CR has had many combinations recently -

Patrick Muirhead & Kristina Moore (Patrick left ages ago)
Murray Dron & Abigail Nance (after Patrick left and Kristina went on maternity)
Kristina Moore & Abigail Nance (cover for Murrary Dron)
Murray Dron & Krisitina Moore (thats the usual)

Having said that, I know of four women newsreaders for CR & CN and only two males...

Murray Dron - Channel Report / Report Sport & Kim Fortune - Channel News

Abigail Nance - Channel Report / Channel News, Kristina Moore - Channel Report, Elaine Carver - Channel News (ex-Channel Report), Katherine Spencer - Channel News

John
PE
Pete Founding member
Noelfirl posted:
Showbizguru posted:
Personally,I think the more female BBC newsreaders the better.
Someone has to tidy up the newsroom.


Oh look, a pretty feeble attempt at controversial commenting. How fascinating


i thought it was quite funny actually
TV
TVN
As did I

Newer posts