The Newsroom

Live From Phuket

(January 2005)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
JW
JamesWorldNews
I am now in Patong Beach, Phuket, and thought I would post this to give a perspective of how the locals see things from here.............

The devastation is something that I just could not imagine until I saw it personally. I came to the region, as I have many friends here and lost contact with many of them when the quake struck last week. It seemed grossly incorrect that I should remain in my cossetted existence in Dubai, whilst those whom I cared for were possibly dead or in terrible suffering.

From the moment I reached Bangkok Airport, it was clear that the international community was mobilised to help. The airport was swarming with uniformed personnel form various international relief agencies and fire rescue crews (on my internal flight to Phuket, it was mainly French personnel), as well as media from every imaginable location.

Upon reaching Phuket Airport itself at midnight on 31st December 2004, no celebrations, other than those who had just landed on the same flight as me, quietly hugging each other in a dignified way, to mark the passing of an old year. However, the task in hand remained at the forefront of everyone's mind.

Upon reaching Patong Beach itself (the site of most of the devastation), the entire town inland was ablaze with the sight of fireworks, and the deafening sound of them was somehow surreal given the circumstances.

The local Thai people remained forever smiling, and I was re-united with some friends who had simply been unable to make contact with me in the preceding week. However, behind the smiles, was very clearly a strained expression and pain deep in their eyes and minds - you would need to be here and know the locals and their ways to fully understand what I am meaning.

Life tries to continue as normal - but it cannot really. The stench is terrible. The devastation is real - it looks just as it does when I saw it a few days ago on BBC World. I don't know why I expected it to be different when I actually got here. All over the town on lamp posts and billboards, there are messages posted for missing persons. It's terribly sad.

And, it is entirely "freaky" somehow to be sitting quitely in bar in a largely deserted holiday resort. Thge music still plays. The shows still go on. Playing largely to empty seats.

And it is even more "freaky" to be sitting in those same bars, and see household names from the BBC, Sky, ITN all walking past me, with their crews and cameras and photographers with their sophisticated cameras carried in bags which appear larger than some Thai homes!!!!!

ITN announced here the night before last that they would be doing a piece on how the local gay community was helping disater victims, by having the famous lady-boys parading in the street, rattling cans and collecting donations for the victims and survivors.

The locals are all bemused my the media presence, but are daily increasingly taking it in their stride.

I was amazed - and slightly amused to be honest - when one Thai friend of mine, pointed to one particular crew that walked past and said 'Oh, those are from Sky News in London......", almost as if it was normal.

They appreciate the seriousness with which the media has handled this story and the sensitivity with which all anchors currently here appear to have shown when presenting live from the beach.

Their biggest concern is about being suddenly forgotten when the next big news story breaks elsewhere. That is probably a reality though.

Are there any plans back in Europe to have a Live Aid type event to help the victims? Isn't someone planning such an event? I think it would go a long way to helping more.

James
SM
smgboi
I understand that Network 9 in Australia is planning a 'live aid' style concert which will be broadcast outside the Sydney Opera House. Every penny made from it will go to the appeal. Channel 7 in Australia will show a special cricket match between an Australian and Asian team, again donating all the profit to the appeal. They will both do a live telethon on the night. Not too sure about the plans here in Britain, but I must applaud Sky News for its amazing coverage. Sensitive, powerful and well presented. They should be proud. The BBC's coverage seems to be pretty poor and I understand the viewing figures reflect that with Sky beating them overwhelmingly. However, at such a sad time, I don't think ratings are the most important thing here. Also, Sky's ticker with messages home is genius. All-in-all I think TV and Radio stations around the world have been sympathetic and, far from moving on to the next story, have dedicated a huge amount of time to covering the disaster.
MQ
Mr Q
smgboi posted:
I understand that Network 9 in Australia is planning a 'live aid' style concert which will be broadcast outside the Sydney Opera House. Every penny made from it will go to the appeal. Channel 7 in Australia will show a special cricket match between an Australian and Asian team, again donating all the profit to the appeal. They will both do a live telethon on the night.

Wrong way around - Nine has the cricket. Originally, Seven was doing the concert, but now it's become a joint effort, with all the commercial FTA networks (Seven, Nine, Ten) coming together to co-produce and broadcast the concert, with all the proceeds going to the charity World Vision.
DO
Dog
BBC WORLD posted:
I am now in Patong Beach, Phuket, and thought I would post this to give a perspective of how the locals see things from here.............


Why are you there.
SM
smgboi
Sorry! Knew it was something like that! Last night in Sweden a TV telethon took place which raised millions. The country's premier took part urging his countrymen to donate money.
CA
cat
Dog posted:
BBC WORLD posted:
I am now in Patong Beach, Phuket, and thought I would post this to give a perspective of how the locals see things from here.............


Why are you there.


I think perhaps if you had bothered yourself to read a little further...

"I came to the region, as I have many friends here and lost contact with many of them when the quake struck last week. It seemed grossly incorrect that I should remain in my cossetted existence in Dubai, whilst those whom I cared for were possibly dead or in terrible suffering."

Not sure ITN's idea of how the local gay community is helping people is particularly newsworthy, if indeed at all. Quite how gay people would help people any differently from straight people in this sort of situation is really beyond me.
IS
Inspector Sands
BBC WORLD posted:
Are there any plans back in Europe to have a Live Aid type event to help the victims? Isn't someone planning such an event? I think it would go a long way to helping more.


Apparently the owners of the Millennium stadium in Cardiff are working on setting up such an event - possibly around the 20th Jan
DO
Dog
cat posted:
Dog posted:
BBC WORLD posted:
I am now in Patong Beach, Phuket, and thought I would post this to give a perspective of how the locals see things from here.............


Why are you there.


I think perhaps if you had bothered yourself to read a little further...

"I came to the region, as I have many friends here and lost contact with many of them when the quake struck last week. It seemed grossly incorrect that I should remain in my cossetted existence in Dubai, whilst those whom I cared for were possibly dead or in terrible suffering."


Yes, perhaps I should have read further on, but seeing as this is someone who usually speaks of nothing other than news presenters, stings, news mucis etc etc, one could quite easily think he went so he could see the news operation there.

And it does actually read that that is the reason why he's gone.

There is more in that post about Sky News, ITV News, BBC etc than his friends.
CO
cortomaltese
Dog posted:
cat posted:
Dog posted:
BBC WORLD posted:
I am now in Patong Beach, Phuket, and thought I would post this to give a perspective of how the locals see things from here.............


Why are you there.


I think perhaps if you had bothered yourself to read a little further...

"I came to the region, as I have many friends here and lost contact with many of them when the quake struck last week. It seemed grossly incorrect that I should remain in my cossetted existence in Dubai, whilst those whom I cared for were possibly dead or in terrible suffering."


Yes, perhaps I should have read further on, but seeing as this is someone who usually speaks of nothing other than news presenters, stings, news mucis etc etc, one could quite easily think he went so he could see the news operation there.

And it does actually read that that is the reason why he's gone.

There is more in that post about Sky News, ITV News, BBC etc than his friends.


Perhaps because in this forum we talk about news presentation and not about his friends.
DO
Dog
cortomaltese posted:
Dog posted:
cat posted:
Dog posted:
BBC WORLD posted:
I am now in Patong Beach, Phuket, and thought I would post this to give a perspective of how the locals see things from here.............


Why are you there.


I think perhaps if you had bothered yourself to read a little further...

"I came to the region, as I have many friends here and lost contact with many of them when the quake struck last week. It seemed grossly incorrect that I should remain in my cossetted existence in Dubai, whilst those whom I cared for were possibly dead or in terrible suffering."


Yes, perhaps I should have read further on, but seeing as this is someone who usually speaks of nothing other than news presenters, stings, news mucis etc etc, one could quite easily think he went so he could see the news operation there.

And it does actually read that that is the reason why he's gone.

There is more in that post about Sky News, ITV News, BBC etc than his friends.


Perhaps because in this forum we talk about news presentation and not about his friends.


You've missed the point of what I was saying.

He's say's he's gone to Phuket to see his friends and to make sure if they're ok. But then spends more time in his post talking about the news operation.

Don't you think there are more important things to say?
CA
cat
To be perfectly honest, I imagine if I were in Phuket looking for friends, the last thing on my mind would be letting people on TV Forum know what I was doing - friends, news presenters, or otherwise.

But each to their own.
TI
timmy
smgboi...

Quote:
The BBC's coverage seems to be pretty poor and I understand the viewing figures reflect that with Sky beating them overwhelmingly. However, at such a sad time, I don't think ratings are the most important thing here


Funnily enough you couldn't be further from the truth.

Amusingly you bash the BBC with the ratings stick and then say that ratings aren't important. Why don't you just tell us what you really think.

Anyway - as I have posted before (with details), from the morning the first news of the crisis broke until January 1st, Sky News and BBC News 24 have pulled level on ratings, according to BARB overnight figures.
At some points BBC News 24 have steamed ahead of Sky News, whilst at others Sky has beaten News 24.

News coverage on BBC One has pulled in some of the biggest audiences of the season, upwards of 7 million, with News 24's audiences leaping by a massive 50%, according to yesterday's Observer.

Maybe your "understanding" of the situation would be better tempered by knowing what's really going on, not what you think is happening. Because judging by what you "understand", it ain't that much.

Newer posts