The Newsroom

Your ideal BBC News

(March 2005)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
EQ
Equidem
All New Johnnyboy posted:
My only substantial change would be one of presentation.

Bring back (something similar to) the 1993-1999 bulletin format - style, music, astons, etc.


Oh, but the BBC people on this forum all CLAIM that era and style was 'pompous'. Well, if it was so bloody pompous in their opinions, why the hell was it kept on air for 8 years with the only change being the logo in 1997?

Nowadays, it's tweak-tweak, fiddle-fiddle and it just looks a total and utter mess. The worst idea the BBC ever had was to make all of it's news output look the same. It didn't work, and it will never work sucessfully.

Heads need to be pulled out of arses at the BBC.
R2
r2ro
Caught the wrong button Sorry
R2
r2ro
I don't really agree with your Breakfast presenters couch_potato . Darren, Sian, Simon and Sophie would be an awful Breakfast, they are all (except Sian) too serious for morning news.
I, on the other hand, would have:

BREAKFAST : Bill Turnbull and Sian Williams
Jon Sopel and Jules Botfield
(Relief) Rob Bonnett and Jane Hill

ONE : Fiona Bruce
Sophie Raworth
(Relief) Liz Pike

SIX : George Alagiah and Moira Staurt
(Relief) Alistair Yates and Susannah Ried

TEN : Dermot Murnaghan
Huw Edwards
(Relief) Darren Jordan

WEEKENDS and HOLIDAYS : Natasha Kaplinsky
Darren Jordan
(Relief) Any other newsreader

BBC NEWS 24
09.00-13.00 (Mon-Fri) : Chris Eakin and Anna Jones
13.00-16.00 (Mon-Fri) : Tim Willcox and Maxine Mawhinney
16.00-19.00 (Mon-Fri) : Matthew Amroliwala and Jane Hill
19.00-23.00 (Mon-Fri) : Simon McCoy and Louise Minchin
23.00-02.00 (Mon-Fri) : Peter Dobbie
02.00-05.00 (Mon-Fri) : Deborah Mackenzie
09.00-14.00 (Sat-Sun) : Carrie Gracie
14.00-19.00 (Sat-Sun) : Peter Sissons
19.00-00.00 (Sat-Sun) : Chris Lowe
00.00-05.00 (Sat-Sun) : Joanna Gosling
Relief : Alistair Yates and Liz Pike
Stephen Cole and Kate Silverton

With Breakfast I would have both presenters doing one month weekdays the next month on weekends.
EG. Month One: Bill and Sian - Weekdays
Jon and Jules - Weekends
Month Two: Jon and Jules - Weekdays
Bill and Sian - Weekends
During holidays I would have Rob presenting with either Jane or Jules.
On the newsdesk I would have the sports presenter and the Breakfast Briefing (which would have sperate titles within Breakfast) would have a further focus on international news stories presented by Susannah Ried or another relief presenter. Then at half six there would be a full summary of the main news and sport with the main presenters for the day (similar to the current briefing) with more reports than interviews. The standard Breakfast would then follow from 6.45.

What do people think about this lineup?
WI
winifred
marykate posted:
Matrix posted:
Natasha would become a reporter, her *cough* talents *cough* are
Matrix


Leave Natasha alone!! she is first and foremost a broadcaster/presenter and a very good one at that bearing in mind the recent award at the TRICs. Sorry to remind you all!!


Well said. The Natasha bashing on this forum is starting to get tiresome.
BN
Breakfast News
winifred posted:
Well said. The Natasha bashing on this forum is starting to get tiresome.


Along with the Natasha, Fiona etc are all so brilliant, fantastic and can do no wrong - that is even more tiresome.
TW
Turnbull and Williams
Breakfast News posted:
winifred posted:
Well said. The Natasha bashing on this forum is starting to get tiresome.


Along with the Natasha, Fiona etc are all so brilliant, fantastic and can do no wrong - that is even more tiresome.


Agree with you 100% BN

Winifred, have you considered that perhaps there's actually more winifred bashing than Natasha bashing going on here...?

And on-topic, I'd like to see Bill and Natasha presenting Breakfast on weekdays, with Chris Eakin and Kate Silverton at weekends - certainly a potentially better combination than dull Jon and flimsy Jules or overbearing Sian.
R2
r2ro
Turnbull & Williams posted:
dull Jon and flimsy Jules


Jon has the right characteristics for Breakfast and can be light hearted, and funny, when appropiate as well as being serious when required.
As for Jules I think she's a great presenter and definitely wouldn't use the adjective 'flimsy' (which is supposed to mean what?)
They were a great pairing when together in the summer of 2003.
MI
Mikeroberts
I would also be in favour of quite a big change... here goes.

All bulletins on BBC1,2 and 4 would come from the same studio (including Breakfast, which would show on News 24 between 6 and Cool. It would have a desk, next to a big plasma, and a soft set, on the opposite side, next to another plasma. The soft set, similar in shape to the current b/fast set would be moveable, to allow a newsreader to stand next to the screen. More importantly, there would be a REAL newsroom for the backdrop.

BBC Morning News 5:30-6:00 am BBC 1 Mon-Fri
with Gillian Joseph or Peter Sissons Relief: Jo Gosling
SET - Newsdesk, or Stood

BBC Breakfast 6:00-9:00 or 9:30 am on BBC1 7days
with Sian Williams and Bill Turnbull, Mishal Hussein and Simon McCoy or Susanna Reid and Jon Sopel
Soft Set
6-8 is newsy progoramme, then 8-end is entertainment.

with Hourly Bulletins with Gillian Joseph or Peter Sissons Relief: Jo Gosling

News Bulletins BBC1 10,11, and 12:00 Mon-Fri
with Fiona Bruce or Phillip Hayton
Soft Set

BBC News at 1 BBC1 1-1:30 Regions 1:30-1:45 Mon-Fri
with Fiona Bruce or Phillip Hayton Relief: Chris Eakin
Desk Set
Concentrating on World News

Afternoon News Bulletins BBC1 3:00 and BBC2 4 and 5:00 Mon-Fri
with Jeremy Paxman, Matthew Amroliwala, Jane Hill, or Natasha Kaplinsky.
Soft Set

BBC News at Six O'Clock BBC1 6:00-6:40 Regional 6:40-7:00 and 6:00-6:15 on Sundays
with Jeremy Paxman and Natasha Kaplinsky, Matthew Amroliwala and Jane Hill , Maxine Mawhinney or Dermot Murnaghan relief: Susanna Reid
1 Presenter at Desk, one presenting lighter news from the soft set. On a very serious news day, e.g. Tsunami, Royal Death, Terrorist Attack or otherwise both presenters may sit at the desk. During major sporting events e.g. Wimbledon the World cup etc both presenters will sit at the desk to make room for a sports presenter on the soft set to do an extended sport buletin.

One presenter would sit at the desk on a Sunday, or at the soft set if the bulletin was moved from 6. This would be either Maxine or Dermot.

At the end of the weekday 6, the presenter who had done the afternoon bulletins would go home.

Evening News Bulletin 8:00, BBC 1 Mon-Fri
Soft Set
with Remaining 6 presenter

The World 8:30 BBC 2 Mon-Fri
Desk
with George Alagiah or Moira Stuart Relief: Mishal Hussein
would replace BBC4 bulletin
If George is presenting, he will also do the 10 later on. If Moira is presenting, Sophie Raworth will do the 10 (along with BBC 4 News).
Ideally, George would do Mon-Wed and Moira Thurs and Fri

BBC 4 News 9:15 BBC 4 Mon-Thurs
Soft Set
with Mark Lawson or Sophie Raworth. Relief: Darren Jordan
News on Literature, film and the arts.

BBC News at 10:00 BBC 1 10-10:20, 7 days Regional -10:30 Mon-Fri
Desk
with George Alagiah (Mon-Wed) or Sophie Raworth (Thurs and Fri) or Dermot Murnaghan/Maxine Mawhinney (Sat and Sun) Relief : Darren Jordan
This shortened progoramme would throw to the regions at 10:20, and the regions would throw back directly into Newsnight at 10:30 (rehearsals for Newsnight would not take place inside the studio, apart from the last 10 mins).

Newsnight 10:30-11:15
with Kirsty Wark, Huw Edwards, Gavin Esler, Michael Buerk or Sarah Montague
Desk
2 of the above presenters, both at Desk. Preferably the same gender.

Weekends

Darren Jordan, Maxine Mawhinney, Dermot Murnaghan, Peter Sissons, Louisa Preston, Louise Minchin, Jo Gosling, Liz Pike.
WI
winifred
Breakfast News posted:

Winifred, have you considered that perhaps there's actually more winifred bashing than Natasha bashing going on here...?



Yes I have but I don't give a t*ss! Laughing
TE
TELEVISION
Since everyone is talking about moving news programmes about, I think I will change some of the stuff I said on the previous page.

BBC 1 NEWS

BBC BREAKFAST NEWS 0600 - 0830

Bill and Sian with Gillian Joseph

This would be a purely news programme, with no soft stories.

BBC BREAKFAST 0830 - 0930

Natasha and Dermot with Gillian Joseph

A programme similar to GMTV's agenda, but not too tabloidy.

ONE 1300 - 1330

Jane or Sophie

SIX 1800 - 1840

Moira or Darren

BBC TEN O'CLOCK NEWS 2200 - 2300

Huw presenting on location, with George and Fiona in the studio.

This would be an internationlly focussed programme, with Huw reporting and presenting the top story from somewhere around the world.

The main weekend bulletin would be at 1800 - 1830 with Matthew Amroliwala, or with another presenter from the main team.

BBC 2 NEWS

BBC NEWSNIGHT 2000 - 2100

Jeremy Paxman, Kirsty Wark, Gavin Esler, Martha Kearney. Any two of these will present on any night. I would move the programme to the earlier time of 2000, when there is no news programme in that slot, and so as not to clash with the Ten.

BBC POLITICS TODAY 2300 - 2330

A new programme with Andrew Neil with a round - up of the days news in Parliament, with a satirical slant, similar to This Week.

I'd keep BBC 3 News and BBC 4 News as they are, except keep the BBC 3 bulletin at 7pm.

Newer posts