The Newsroom

HAITI QUAKE - COMBINED DISCUSSION

(January 2010)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
:-(
A former member
Does anyone know who Fox News have sent to the scene? I watched a clip on youtube and If I recall right Wendel Goler was on holiday in the Santo Dominico when it happened. So i presume he would have been sent?
NE
Newsroom
Does anyone know who Fox News have sent to the scene? I watched a clip on youtube and If I recall right Wendel Goler was on holiday in the Santo Dominico when it happened. So i presume he would have been sent?


When I was watching in the states from the moment it broke to Thurs PM - Fox news were diabolical in their coverage.
SC
Schwing
Does anyone know who Fox News have sent to the scene? I watched a clip on youtube and If I recall right Wendel Goler was on holiday in the Santo Dominico when it happened. So i presume he would have been sent?


When I was watching in the states from the moment it broke to Thurs PM - Fox news were diabolical in their coverage.


I think it's a little unfair to say that the coverage on Fox has been diabolical. Although CNN was first to break the story, it was Fox that was first with a report from a correspondent. There's been a lot of criticism leveled at Fox in the last few days, with claims that it put an exclusive interview with Sarah Palin above the news from Haiti. To be fair, there was little that could be done (or discovered) given the time at which the earthquake occurred; the diminishing light would have hampered any attempts to get people into the country and the lack of communications made things extremely difficult.

It should be pointed out, however, that although CNN - and in particular Anderson Cooper - has been praised for its coverage, there is a significant caveat to this; critiques by the New York Times , Washington Post and the LA Times all compared Fox's decision to stay with taped programming on the night of the earthquake with CNN's coverage in the days that followed. Why did these critiques not examine CNN's coverage on the evening it occurred? Because it had no resources in the area and Anderson Cooper - against whose coverage everybody's else's has been compared - was en route to the region. Is it me, or isn't it a little unfair (to say the least) to compare the coverage of one network in the immediate aftermath with that of another a day later, by which time it had mobilised its resources and had an anchor on the ground? Additionally, if you would like an example of diabolical coverage, you should try MSNBC - their coverage has been, and continues to be, a shambles.
NE
Newsroom
BBC News to my knowledge has a hefty team there now:

Matt Frie
George Alagiah
Matthew Price
Mark Doyle
David Loyn
Andrew Gallacher
Ian Sherwood

And more tomorrow I am sure.

Interesting that many of the Beeb's team appear to be fluent in French. Logistical or chance?
NE
Newsroom
Does anyone know who Fox News have sent to the scene? I watched a clip on youtube and If I recall right Wendel Goler was on holiday in the Santo Dominico when it happened. So i presume he would have been sent?


When I was watching in the states from the moment it broke to Thurs PM - Fox news were diabolical in their coverage.


I think it's a little unfair to say that the coverage on Fox has been diabolical. Although CNN was first to break the story, it was Fox that was first with a report from a correspondent. There's been a lot of criticism leveled at Fox in the last few days, with claims that it put an exclusive interview with Sarah Palin above the news from Haiti. To be fair, there was little that could be done (or discovered) given the time at which the earthquake occurred; the diminishing light would have hampered any attempts to get people into the country and the lack of communications made things extremely difficult.

It should be pointed out, however, that although CNN - and in particular Anderson Cooper - has been praised for its coverage, there is a significant caveat to this; critiques by the New York Times , Washington Post and the LA Times all compared Fox's decision to stay with taped programming on the night of the earthquake with CNN's coverage in the days that followed. Why did these critiques not examine CNN's coverage on the evening it occurred? Because it had no resources in the area and Anderson Cooper - against whose coverage everybody's else's has been compared - was en route to the region. Is it me, or isn't it a little unfair (to say the least) to compare the coverage of one network in the immediate aftermath with that of another a day later, by which time it had mobilised its resources and had an anchor on the ground? Additionally, if you would like an example of diabolical coverage, you should try MSNBC - their coverage has been, and continues to be, a shambles.


I agree on some of your points, however it was Anderson Cooper who had the first report from the scene as documented widely. CNN IMO have provided incredible coverage though I do have criticism with their coverage of THEIR own rescue of survivors - CNN's Doctor weighing in, Anderson seen helping to pull people from the rubble... and so on.
NE
Newsroom
George presenting the ONE from Haiti.

Ben Brown now there presenting for the News Channel.
Last edited by Newsroom on 18 January 2010 2:46pm
NE
newsatten
For those who asked earlier about where the TV crews sleep ect.
This is what ITV news do at least.

http://tweetphoto.com/8942939
http://tweetphoto.com/8960954
LO
Londoner
Round-up of how UK broadcasters are covering the quake:
http://www.pressgazette.co.uk/story.asp?sectioncode=1&storycode=44924&c=1
NE
Newsroom
It really is surprising that SKY haven't sent any presenters to Haiti, and nothing about the fact anywhere on the internet. They're usually blasted for over exposure at times of disaster, but on this occasion, probably the worst we've witnessed in decades - and not one presenter and only 3 correspondents covering events. All very bizarre.
MA
Markymark
Round-up of how UK broadcasters are covering the quake:
http://www.pressgazette.co.uk/story.asp?sectioncode=1&storycode=44924&c=1


I'm rather confused, given that article states the BBC have their own uplink there, why their reports should have NTSC footprints ?

I also don't think it's terribly clever for 30 of them to be using a hotel.
LJ
Live at five with Jeremy
I think Jon Snow's coverage has been really fantastic. He is given the chance to do some reports and not just anchoring. Dominic Waghorn was also a great person to send as he has experience in disaster zones
DV
DVB Cornwall
According to the trailer tonight's Newswatch is dealing with issues relating to the BBC Coverage.

Newer posts