The Newsroom

Flash flooding in Cornwall

BBC v ITV v Sky (August 2004)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
CW
cwathen Founding member
Quote:
Frankly, that's pathetic. I gather the headlines are recorded, but surely they could have done an amended sequence to at least mention it.

Not as pathetic as Westcountry Television - total airtime given to the story was 3 minutes, no updates through the evening even though they are alledgedly our regional TV company, no acknowledgment of it on the recorded weather forecast.

Spotlight on the other hand hasn't spoken about anything else since it started, have allready had David Braine talking about the weather angle on it, aswell as giving advice about updates on Radio Cornwall.
FU
fusionlad Founding member
Spotlight now showing viewers footage e-mailed to them.
CW
cwathen Founding member
Spotlight also pledging to keep making updates throughout the programme, and have now 'moved on to today's other news' - said in such a tone that they are clearly acknowledging that it pails in comparison.
OH
ohwhatanight Founding member
ITV News have just mentioned it and replayed that awful media player clip!

Im just flicking between Sky News and BBC News 24 and BBC is vastly superior ! A great aerial shot whereas SKy are currently showing emailed photos!

I wonder if ITV News will make an effort at 7pm or just totally ignore the story?
LO
Londoner
ohwhatanight posted:
I wonder if ITV News will make an effort at 7pm or just totally ignore the story?

I expect they will make an effort - they were doing quite well up to 6.30 - just as many phone interviews as Sky.
FU
fusionlad Founding member
So where have these helicopter shots come from? Are they BBC camermen or from the RAF? Is there away that Sky can 'buy' the pictures from the BBC, or will they wait for their own resources?

How long would it take the SkyCopter to get from London to North Cornwall? I just get the feeling it wont even be sent.
OH
ohwhatanight Founding member
Well listening to the viewer speaking to BBC News 24 she said she could see FIVE helicopters in the sky. I could identify two as yellow RAF helicopters but I wonder what the other helicopters were?
FU
fusionlad Founding member
Spotlight now have their top reporter in Boscastle, although no picture feed yet.

This story is going to be very big. Boscastle is described as totally devistated.

EDIT: Make that TWO reporters from Spotlight.
LO
Londoner
ITV News made it their second story in the headline recap.

And they tried unsuccessfully to talk to the person who sent the video.
FU
fusionlad Founding member
7 helicopters on scene, all from official authorities. No news helicopters.

Spotlight reporting buildings are starting to collapse.
OH
ohwhatanight Founding member
ITV News on ITV1 have returned to the story where Nic Owen said, "this is the latest situation" repeating the media clips again! A phone caller failed and Nic filled until the important John Prescott story!
CW
cwathen Founding member
Spotlight has spent all but about 5 minutes of their programme on it so far, making Westcountry's feeble efforts look even more of a shambles.

This to me highlights the reason why ITV's nationalisation is wrong - the token shells left of what were once regional television companies are completely incapable of dealing with anything that can't be carefully planned in advance. Even their Weather forecast was the usual pre-recorded one which didn't even ackowledge the incident. 12 years ago, TSW would have been ditching the network schedule in order to cover this story, with updates made in between programmes (or even in the continuity announcements to programmes). Westcountry on the other hand will receive no extra updates because ITV1 towers in London don't see the importance, and when it did have the opportunity of half an hour's airtime, they instead were running pointless carefully planned lives to Athens just because someone won a medal who once lived in Ivybridge and giving a genuinely relevant and important regional story next to no coverage because it happened to quickly for them to respond. It's beyond a joke that people claim modern 'ITV1' is better than ITV of the past, it really is.

Newer posts