The Newsroom

Final election programme for David Dimbleby

Huw Edwards after 2015. Split from UK Election debates (February 2014)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
:-(
A former member
Quote:
The Bill makes provision for elections to be called earlier under only two exceptional circumstances. Parliament can be dissolved early if:

at least two thirds of MPs vote for dissolution
a Government is unable to secure the confidence of the House of Commons within 14 days of a no-confidence vote.
For the no confidence vote, a simple majority of fifty per cent plus one will be required. The Fixed-term Parliaments Bill now goes forward for Royal Assent when it will formally become an Act.


It would have not stopped the 1979 election Wink
MA
Markymark
http://www.bbc.co.uk/mediacentre/latestnews/2014/general-election-2015.html

The BBC is delighted to announce that David Dimbleby will be the lead presenter of the general election programme on the night of Thursday 7 May 2015, .


Errr, that's a very likely date for the GE, but it's not a 100% certainty. What an extraordinary piece of speculation dressed up as fact !

Since the passing of the Fixed-Term Parliaments Bill in 2011, each government now lasts five years with an exact end date, rather than the prime minister being free to choose a date as previously.

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/historic-bill-establishes-fixed-term-parliaments


Well, thanks for the correction. I don't recall that being publicised at all, but I was abroad on Sept 14th 2011,
so I must have totally missed the news ! I'll get me coat.......... Embarassed
:-(
A former member
I dare say many expected a vote of no confidence would taken place already, confusing alot of people about this new set up
SI
sigma421
Interesting line at the end of that press release. It says Edwards will present the referendum coverage 'from Glasgow'. That backs up what I thought might be the case. They have permission to keep the Commonwealth Games studios at Pacific Quay in Glasgow until the end of September.

Why? Isn't it most likely that they'll just build a set in Studios A or B and be done with it. Worked fine for the 2011 Scottish Parliament election.
JO
Jon
Odd that at ITV, elections are Alastair's ground yet big events (news or state occasions) are Mark's yet the BBC are giving everything to Huw.

It's not odd. It's different decisions by different management about different people.

It would be odd if they just mirrored every decision.
WO
Worzel
House posted:
Jeremy Paxman would have been my choice. A lot of what Dimbleby does is interview party representatives, not simply report statistical updates. Not only is Paxman still one of the finest interviewers, but would make the coverage far more entertaining than Edwards will.

Honestly a little disappointed this will be Dimbleby's last - certainly in 2010 he was on top form, and adds a special quality to the broadcast that betrays the BBC's current transition to very competent, yet straight/boring presenters (a la Edwards). At least the BBC has gone for a transition to a new presenter, instead of just not inviting Dimbleby back again. My suspicion is this will be Nick Robinson's last election, at least as political editor, but I could be wrong.

It is worth noting that the article doesn't say Dimbleby is retiring per se, so much as being replaced as lead presenter. I suspect it's unlikely (when you consider the role the likes of Beurk and Sissons have played in coverage [of any kind] after being replaced), but I'd like to think Dimbleby will continue to play some kind of secondary role in election coverage for as long as he can and wants to. I certainly can't imagine them replacing him on Question Time any time soon.

Quote:
Dimbleby and the rest of the overnight presentation team will hand over to Edwards and a fresh line-up of BBC presenters and correspondents

I suspect Mishal Husain could well be part of election coverage next year, either for Today or the main television programme. Ditto for Laura Kuenssberg - it will be interesting to see what her role is compared James Landale.

Also, while this press release hasn't provided details of the rest of the onair team (and indeed such decisions might not yet have been made), I wonder if Jeremy Vine will return at the green screen / swingometer? I can somehow imagine someone like Laura Kuenssberg taking over this role sometime in the future...


Thing is surely the need to find something for Jeremy Vine to do. Apart from appearing at election time, his TV appearances are few and far between (Radio 2 aside). My money's on Jeremy Vine replacing David D on Question Time in the next 5 years.
CA
Cando
Odd that at ITV, elections are Alastair's ground yet big events (news or state occasions ) are Mark's yet the BBC are giving everything to Huw.


Wasn't the ITV Coverage Royal wedding and Jubilee coverage presented by Julie with Philip Schofield? and it was Alistair who did the brief coverage/updates during Thatcher's funeral. Doesn't he do the budget as well?
DV
DVB Cornwall
Vine is my suggestion for a TV role too, opens his slot on R2 for the 'Female Daytime Presenter' that some are craving for too. Who that might be is beyond the scope of this discussion.
SP
Steve in Pudsey
I guess Broadcasting House doesn't have any N9-esque studios spare they can occupy for 24 hours or so.


Once Studio D opens they probably could free up a studio by the kind of studio sharing arrangement they are using now.
TVF
TV Forum Team
This topic has been moved from TV Home Forum .
SW
Steve Williams
Thing is surely the need to find something for Jeremy Vine to do. Apart from appearing at election time, his TV appearances are few and far between (Radio 2 aside). My money's on Jeremy Vine replacing David D on Question Time in the next 5 years.


Maybe he doesn't want to be on the telly, he likes his job on Radio 2 which is very high profile. More people listen to him than watch Newsnight or The Daily Politics or even Question Time. If he ever wants to give up his job on Radio 2 (and Jimmy Young was in that slot for thirty years) it'll probably be because he's fed up of doing daily shows and wants to make documentaries or something.
SW
Steve Williams
Jon posted:
It's not odd. It's different decisions by different management about different people.

It would be odd if they just mirrored every decision.


And it's certainly not a hard and fast rule anyway, because in the seventies and eighties Alastair Burnet did the lot, elections, weddings, everything. It just so happens that at the moment it seems Stewart is good at the political stuff while Austin maybe less so, or less interested, and is better on the state occasions (although as pointed out, he doesn't really do them much). Whereas Edwards likes and is good at both. I think so, anyway, I think he's a very warm presenter.

It's probably right to say that Dimbleby will still be involved in election coverage in years to come, very much like how Jonathan Dimbleby was replaced as ITV's anchor on election night in 2010 but still presented programmes during the build-up.

Of course on BBC Parliament tomorrow is Election 74 again, with Alastair Burnet in charge, who I don't think is very good at all, he doesn't seem to gel with his colleagues and is very dull. However grim the election was. There are moments when he looks at results from safe seats and goes "none of these are particularly interesting", which is bad manners because obviously if it's your constituency, it's very interesting.

Newer posts