The Newsroom

Resignations from Government (Presentation discussion)

Currently David Davis and Boris Johnson (July 2018)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
IT
itsrobert Founding member
I seem to recall Yes Minister gave a pretty good insight into that.

I can almost hear Sir Humphrey bemoaning the fact that the minister merely gets in the way of good government.

If anyone hasn't watched Yes Minister before, I would strongly recommend it. It may be over 30-odd years old but it's as relevant today as it ever was. One of the very best sitcoms Britain has ever produced.
SP
Steve in Pudsey
Never really understood how being culture secretary prepared you for being health secretary.

To be fair all cabinet reshuffles puzzle me, at a moments notice you have a completely different brief.

Imagine if that happened in other jobs

Accounts, you’re now doing HR. HR you’re now in Marketing..


Happens in journalism.

Politcal Correspondent? Now you're Business Editor.
:-(
A former member
The member requested removal of this post
RK
Rkolsen
Well he seems happy about it.

Rare to get a newsflash nowadays .


Although they do seem to be making a bit of a comeback as we got one for Bruce Forsyth death last year.


I love a proper mainstream channel newsflash. They always give a kind of shiver of terrified anticipation for a few seconds as you wonder how dreadful the news might be.


I do too. But here in the US they are becoming so common (twice a week almost). Including tonight for the SCOTUS nominee.
IS
Inspector Sands
Never really understood how being culture secretary prepared you for being health secretary.

To be fair all cabinet reshuffles puzzle me, at a moments notice you have a completely different brief.

Imagine if that happened in other jobs

Accounts, you’re now doing HR. HR you’re now in Marketing..

Apparently the UK is one of the few countries where cabinet members have to be taken from the pool of elected representatives.


Elsewhere they can just recruit people from outside government who are experts in that field (or in the case of the US at the moment, those who are directly opposed to that field!)

One advantage of that is that they're not having to juggle both their cabinet job and their constituency
SP
Steve in Pudsey
There is precident for installing such an expert in the Lords and making them a minister.
LS
Lou Scannon
There is precident ...


Is that some sort of a cross between a Precedent and a President?
NG
noggin Founding member

One advantage of that is that they're not having to juggle both their cabinet job and their constituency


You don't have to be an MP though, you can also be a member of the House of Lords (which don't have constituency responsibilities in the same way)

Gordon Brown's 'Government of all the talents' included a number of ministers appointed from the House of Lords (and not necessarily Labour Party members) - I think including cabinet roles.
WO
Worzel

One advantage of that is that they're not having to juggle both their cabinet job and their constituency


You don't have to be an MP though, you can also be a member of the House of Lords (which don't have constituency responsibilities in the same way)

Gordon Brown's 'Government of all the talents' included a number of ministers appointed from the House of Lords (and not necessarily Labour Party members) - I think including cabinet roles.


Lord Adonis as Transport Secretary was one example. He even held Transport Questions in the Lords. Was an interesting watch.
DV
dvboy
Yesterday's flash
RO
Rory
dvboy posted:
Yesterday's flash


Those Wimbledon players really should wear bigger shorts.

I'll get me coat.
:-(
A former member
The member requested removal of this post

Newer posts