The Newsroom

Manchester Terror Attack

On 22 May 2017, there was a suicide bombing at Manchester Arena which killed 22 people (May 2017)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
NE
Newsroom
Ben Bland replacing Tom Donkin at 5am joining David Eades on BBC News.
TV
TVDP
Where is ITN tonight ?
BA
bilky asko
The way some people are going on here, you'd think the BBC coverage was unwatchable.

A press conference, which was largely a rehash of a tweet and with little new information, wasn't shown live. No real issue there.

Yes, there was no useless tower cam shot. And yes, early live coverage was off a phone. But there were decent eyewitness accounts, reliable US sources were quoted, and the made up figures floating around Twitter (along with false images and video) were ignored. Barring the top of the hour camera issues, and the long delay at one point (which was well handled by not having constant questions punctuating proceedings), I think the coverage has been good.
NE
Newsroom
TVDP posted:
Where is ITN tonight ?


Not a single news report since it began. Shocking.
NE
Newsroom
The way some people are going on here, you'd think the BBC coverage was unwatchable.

A press conference, which was largely a rehash of a tweet and with little new information, wasn't shown live. No real issue there.

Yes, there was no useless tower cam shot. And yes, early live coverage was off a phone. But there were decent eyewitness accounts, reliable US sources were quoted, and the made up figures floating around Twitter (along with false images and video) were ignored. Barring the top of the hour camera issues, and the long delay at one point (which was well handled by not having constant questions punctuating proceedings), I think the coverage has been good.


Not really. Compare it to what CNN pulled out of the bag. Max Foster in the studio, Paul Cruikshank at the London studio within an hour of it happening. A huge number of specialists, guests throughout the night. I'm not sure the BBC managed any specialists at all. It has been pretty dire.
MW
Mike W




Didn't know the LUL had a line all the way to Manchester!
BA
bilky asko
The way some people are going on here, you'd think the BBC coverage was unwatchable.

A press conference, which was largely a rehash of a tweet and with little new information, wasn't shown live. No real issue there.

Yes, there was no useless tower cam shot. And yes, early live coverage was off a phone. But there were decent eyewitness accounts, reliable US sources were quoted, and the made up figures floating around Twitter (along with false images and video) were ignored. Barring the top of the hour camera issues, and the long delay at one point (which was well handled by not having constant questions punctuating proceedings), I think the coverage has been good.


Not really. Compare it to what CNN pulled out of the bag. Max Foster in the studio, Paul Cruikshank at the London studio within an hour of it happening. A huge number of specialists, guests throughout the night. I'm not sure the BBC managed any specialists at all. It has been pretty dire.


Specialists in what? Speculation?
guest03, UKnews and Inspector Sands gave kudos
NE
Newsroom
The way some people are going on here, you'd think the BBC coverage was unwatchable.

A press conference, which was largely a rehash of a tweet and with little new information, wasn't shown live. No real issue there.

Yes, there was no useless tower cam shot. And yes, early live coverage was off a phone. But there were decent eyewitness accounts, reliable US sources were quoted, and the made up figures floating around Twitter (along with false images and video) were ignored. Barring the top of the hour camera issues, and the long delay at one point (which was well handled by not having constant questions punctuating proceedings), I think the coverage has been good.


Not really. Compare it to what CNN pulled out of the bag. Max Foster in the studio, Paul Cruikshank at the London studio within an hour of it happening. A huge number of specialists, guests throughout the night. I'm not sure the BBC managed any specialists at all. It has been pretty dire.


Specialists in what? Speculation?


Experts, specialists, crime/terrorist/ correspondents, etc.... The kind of people you'd expect to pop up between the hours of 6am and 11pm on BBC News. It fell short of delivering what it should. I'm English and live in the states, I've been watching it, and others throughout the night.
DK
DanielK
GMB have come on air, with Piers and Susanna in London, reverted to the old theme however.
RO
rob Founding member
No 6.10am ITV Regional news bulletin due to the breaking news coverage.
AN
Andrew Founding member
TVDP posted:
Where is ITN tonight ?


Not a single news report since it began. Shocking.
there is loads online, news isn't just on the TV in this day and age, in fact more will see the ITV News online channels than a news flash on ITV at3am
AA
Aaron_2015
I'm sure if they could have done a bulletin, ITV would have. However, there will have been very few staff at ITN so early in the morning. Moreover, there would have been very few people (tens of thousands) actually watching.

Newer posts