The Newsroom

BBC News Journalists to stage 2 48 Hour Strikes

5th-6th & 15th-16th November (October 2010)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
HO
House
House posted:
House posted:
I wouldn't think Peter would be in the journalists union, what with his cheesy DJ background.


And yet - as someone pointed out to me yesterday - the likes of Richard Bacon have been absent despite being little more than a presenter. Not that I have a problem with this, but would someone like that really be a member of the NUJ?


You don't have to be a member of the NUJ to have a problem crossing a picket line. I know a number of non-union presenters who won't do it out of principle.


And that's true, though those who are absent and aren't entitled to strike action through their union are breaking a whole heap of laws and rules.


Out of interest, who do we think would come off worse for their actions in career terms? A so called "scab" like Emma Crosby, or a very public protester like Newsnight's Paul Mason?


As a general rule, I don't think 'scab' presenters have tended to benefit particularly from crossing a picket line. But I think Emma Crosby is going to be a huge success at the Beeb. She's stunningly attractive and a good presenter. I think she'll be presenting network blletins full-time pretty soon and is likely to become one of the 'faces' of BBC News.


While it's true 'scab' presenters have tended not to do so well, in the last strike there wasn't as senior or high-profiled presenter on as Emma Crosby or Simon McCoy.

But as the News at One today showed, Emma Crosby fits with the BBC perfectly - better in fact than she did at GMTV or Sky, in my opinion. I agree, it would be great for her to get to do network bulletins full-time - the question, however, is where there's a gap.
JA
Jamesypoo
First appearance of the breakdown slide?

*

http://www.tvnewsbreak.co.uk/video/videos/bbc-breakdown_conv.flv

Alastair Yates said it was nothing to do with the strike.
Last edited by Jamesypoo on 6 November 2010 4:29am - 2 times in total
BP
Bob Paisley
House posted:
House posted:
House posted:
I wouldn't think Peter would be in the journalists union, what with his cheesy DJ background.


And yet - as someone pointed out to me yesterday - the likes of Richard Bacon have been absent despite being little more than a presenter. Not that I have a problem with this, but would someone like that really be a member of the NUJ?


You don't have to be a member of the NUJ to have a problem crossing a picket line. I know a number of non-union presenters who won't do it out of principle.


And that's true, though those who are absent and aren't entitled to strike action through their union are breaking a whole heap of laws and rules.


Out of interest, who do we think would come off worse for their actions in career terms? A so called "scab" like Emma Crosby, or a very public protester like Newsnight's Paul Mason?


As a general rule, I don't think 'scab' presenters have tended to benefit particularly from crossing a picket line. But I think Emma Crosby is going to be a huge success at the Beeb. She's stunningly attractive and a good presenter. I think she'll be presenting network blletins full-time pretty soon and is likely to become one of the 'faces' of BBC News.


While it's true 'scab' presenters have tended not to do so well, in the last strike there wasn't as senior or high-profiled presenter on as Emma Crosby or Simon McCoy.

But as the News at One today showed, Emma Crosby fits with the BBC perfectly - better in fact than she did at GMTV or Sky, in my opinion. I agree, it would be great for her to get to do network bulletins full-time - the question, however, is where there's a gap.


If the powers-that-be want there to be a gap - one will appear. It's happened in the past. Anna Jones was quickly got rid of when they wanted to find a regular slot for Kate Silverton. At the very least I think Emma Crosby will have a regular slot on the News Channel before long - and network bulletins will soon follow.

Call me Mystic Bob.
SD
SDLF
Breakfast on air now, with Charlie Stayt and Anna Davies, at least I think that's her name.(didn't quite catch what they said at the beginning).

EDIT: Anne Davies. According to the Internet she is a presenter on East Midlands Today.
Last edited by SDLF on 6 November 2010 6:33am
JT
jolly turnip
SDLF posted:
Breakfast on air now, with Charlie Stayt and Anna Davies, at least I think that's her name.(didn't quite catch what they said at the beginning).

EDIT: Anne Davies. According to the Internet she is a presenter on East Midlands Today.


A return to national breakfast. Of course she was the first presenter of GMTV alongside Eamonn Holmes. Continuing presenting Fri - Sun programmes, and laterly the news on the weekday shows. Before moving back to the East Midlands (previously Central News East).

Doing a very good job as well - as you would expect
CH
chris_rgu
BBC World just left breakfast
LO
LONDON
I have to say this morning is just like the normal weekend edition of Breakfast, the only exception being Anne and Charlie were both on at 6am, when there is normally just one presenter for the first hour. I wonder if Charlie is not striking why he was not on yesterday morning.
RO
Ronant
5live simulcasting Australia's ABC Radio Grandstand programme. Commentary on the Aus- NZ rugby league match plus Australian cricket updates.
RO
Ronant
Breakfast on tv remarkably similar to normal, they're not mentioning the strike now. Anne Davies is fab - would like to see more of her.
JT
jolly turnip
House posted:
I wouldn't think Peter would be in the journalists union, what with his cheesy DJ background.


And yet - as someone pointed out to me yesterday - the likes of Richard Bacon have been absent despite being little more than a presenter. Not that I have a problem with this, but would someone like that really be a member of the NUJ?


But what we need to think about is the journalists/NUJ members working behind the scenes on Five Live as well as all the other BBC output. That will have hit both Five Live and the NEws Channel hard
AQ
Aquasetia
It was a Friday. Richard Bacon is not due to be on on a Friday - it's Mayo and Kermode.
JT
jolly turnip
Dobbie at 10am

Newer posts