The Newsroom

BBC changes policy on royal/high profile deaths

(February 2010)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
JV
James Vertigan Founding member
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1252557/Five-Royal-Family-demoted-BBC-changes-protocol-broadcast-death-list.html

Look out - it's a Mail On Sunday article!!

Quote:
The BBC has downgraded five senior members of the Royal Family by ordering that their deaths should no longer trigger an automatic interruption of normal broadcasts.
Prince Harry, Princess Anne, Princes Andrew and Edward and the Countess of Wessex had formerly belonged to a special BBC list known as Category 2, which has now been abolished.
The list meant a specific ‘obituary procedure’ would be followed when they died, including news flashes and the broadcasting of pre-prepared documentaries

But now they are in a category known as ‘other notables’, which also includes Muhammad Ali, Lech Walesa and Bob Dylan. Their deaths will be regarded as ‘major breaking news stories with coverage on merit’.
The new protocol has been drawn up by a group of senior BBC executives, including deputy director general Mark Byford.
The details, seen by The Mail on Sunday, have been sent to all senior BBC news staff, editors, producers and reporters.
Also demoted are Prime Minister Gordon Brown, the Leader of the Opposition David Cameron and the President of the United States Barack Obama, who had previously been in Category 2.

Now they are on the same list as Camilla, Duchess of Cornwall, the Archbishop of Canterbury, the Pope, the Dalai Lama, Margaret Thatcher, Nelson Mandela, Tony Blair, Nick Clegg, Sir John Major and Mikhail Gorbachev.
The elite Category 1 remains unchanged. This consists of only the Queen, the Duke of Edinburgh, Prince Charles and Prince William.
If they die there will be ‘the immediate interruption of BBC1, BBC2 and the BBC News Channel’, with an ‘official announcement – normally via a Buckingham Palace statement’.
Neither the BBC nor Buckingham Palace would comment on the changes.


Discuss. if you so wish!
Last edited by James Vertigan on 21 February 2010 7:12pm
MA
mark Founding member
Despite the very Daily Mail topline, I actually find this bit more important...

Quote:

Also demoted are Prime Minister Gordon Brown, the Leader of the Opposition David Cameron and the President of the United States Barack Obama, who had previously been in Category 2.


I think it really just reflects how the way these things are covered has changed. Clearly nowadays, if Gordon Brown or Barack Obama died in office, the BBC would want to broadcast rolling news coverage - not the more sombre, reflective programming that the Category 2 procedure required.
NJ
news junkie
If a high profile person such as Obama or Brown etc. BBC News Channel would cover the story non-stop. All it means is that it would not disrupt everyone(BBC One, Two etc)
GI
ginnyfan
That's strange, they interrupted BBC One for MJ death but wouldn't do it for high profile leaders of countries??? Shocked
IS
Inspector Sands
That's strange, they interrupted BBC One for MJ death but wouldn't do it for high profile leaders of countries??? Shocked

Did they? Which programmes were interrupted?
AN
Andrew Founding member
Although they have this official procedure, I'm sure in practice if and when they interupt programmes is also dependant on the importance of the programme that would be interupted, the time of day and what the competition is doing.
DV
DVB Cornwall
Pinch of Salt... take with.

Any VIP death, especially if unepected (MJ), would be covered at length on all BBC channels regardless of whatever list they might be on. The more extraordinary the circumstances dictating the degree of simultaneity.

Take the Currrent Pope, He's old but in reasonably good health, if he died tonight, there'd be wall to wall coverage. In the Case of JPII he was known to be ill and his death 'expected' therefore a simple Newsflash on BBCONE directing attention to BBC NEWS and an extension to scheduled bulletins sufficed.

Expect some denial or 'clarification' from the BBC on this if the list story develops overnight.
RE
Revitt
That's strange, they interrupted BBC One for MJ death but wouldn't do it for high profile leaders of countries??? Shocked

Did they? Which programmes were interrupted?


IIRC, it was only a news report.
EX
excel99
With regards to the PM etc the key phrase for me is: "major breaking news stories with coverage on merit". Nothing stopping interruptions on BBC1 - indeed surely if Gordon Brown or Barack Obama died right now most people would expect an announcement and breaking news coverage on BBC1?

All these changes appear to do is remove the need to interupt BBC2, Local Radio etc for all but the most senior members of the Royal Family. And it would seem quite odd to me anyway interrupting Radio Humberside to announce the death of the American President ...
WE
Westy2
With regards to the PM etc the key phrase for me is: "major breaking news stories with coverage on merit". Nothing stopping interruptions on BBC1 - indeed surely if Gordon Brown or Barack Obama died right now most people would expect an announcement and breaking news coverage on BBC1?

All these changes appear to do is remove the need to interupt BBC2, Local Radio etc for all but the most senior members of the Royal Family. And it would seem quite odd to me anyway interrupting Radio Humberside to announce the death of the American President ...


And we'd miss WM, C & W, Stoke, Shropshire & Hereford & Worcester all joining for a special 3 hour programme live from Brum with Ed Doolan getting your views, inbetween linking to the national output, like they did for the Queen Mum!
JV
James Vertigan Founding member
That's strange, they interrupted BBC One for MJ death but wouldn't do it for high profile leaders of countries??? Shocked

Did they? Which programmes were interrupted?


IIRC, it was only a news report.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YhdrEy2t3ww

It was - as this clip demonstrates it was straight ater Question Time and introduced with the Helicopter ident.
BR
Brekkie
They're damned if they do, damned if they don't. It all depends on how the story breaks really and also the programmes on at the time - if the next junction is ten minutes or so away they're more likely to hold on than if they've just began broadcasting a film.

Newer posts