The Newsroom

BBC Breakfast

From 6am (April 2012)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
MA
Markymark
Moz posted:
They'd be better off abandoning the whole disaster and moving back to London.

What disaster?

When it was in London it had the same number of down-the-line feeds to Westminster and everywhere else, just like as it comes from Salford, Even the guests are as of the high calibre - just because they are London based does not mean they are better!

Ratings for the programme are just as strong, if not stronger and the presenters are well established, now, and well liked by viewers and guests alike!!!

So to say it is a disaster is completely wrong and possibly shows a bit of jealousy!

From my own point of view, moving it from London has helped it get closer to the majority of British people who do NOT live in the capital, as it now features more "national" reports rather than London-centric reports.


You're talking crap and you know it. It's gone from being in a big black box in London with lots of screens, to being in a big black box in Salford with lots of screens. Only instead of London based toffs telling us what's what, we get Manchester based ones. It's no different and was just a waste of money.


If you accept the move was political and waste of money - and most people do - the programme as a whole hasn't suffered. The point I would make is that nothing has been gained. Nothing has improved by the wider Salford move. If moving productions North was such a good idea, why for instance would you shoot a northern comedy 'still open all hours' at the Teddington Studios?

Its very expensive political cobblers - instead of money spent on programming and therefore industry jobs its gone on buildings which are, in the case of Salford, badly designed and expensive to lease.



The Beeb don't make any feature or 'USP' about the programme coming from Salford. I'm sure
a good chunk of the audience simply assume it's from London.

It's not like the 70s, and programmes such as Pebble Mill at One , where it was abundantly
clear they were in Brum, and proud of the fact. Sale of the Century made a feature
of coming from Norwich. The Tube from Newcastle, etc.

The only reference to Breakfast's location is when BBC South's Roger Finn hands back the opt, saying, 'Back to Bill and Louise in Salford' .
DE
deejay
That's only because Roger has always done that, but in the past has said "now it's back to London"!
MI
m_in_m
What the move has done, in my mind, is reduce the London bias of experts used across BBC News. Now at least during Breakfast there is a greater chance that experts from outside London will appear on the programme - even if this doesn't still represent the entire of the UK. A greater plurality of voices across BBC News output has to be welcomed.
weaz and Steve in Pudsey gave kudos
AC
aconnell
I think of particular note has been the business news. Far less City-centric, more coverage of the rest of UK from all sorts of businesses and sectors - big or small. And as m_in_m says, a wider range of experts, particularly from North West universities, such as the super-local Universities of Salford and Manchester.

9 days later

:-(
A former member
BBC Breakfast has a good line up of presenters I think. Laughing
DO
dosxuk
Thanks for that...
SA
salfordjohn
New 'Contact Us' animations above the clock being used this morning. Not constant.. Only seen it once. Just the BBC News standard 'wipe' as used on the main news when plugging the twitter accounts of Nick Robinson etc. but an orange bar not white. It loops through Contact us / bbcbreakfast@bbc.co.uk / @bbcbreakfast / #bbcbreakfast / Contact Us / ....... It also moves up on top of the name aston if it hasn't gone through the loops.
HB
HarryB
New 'Contact Us' animations above the clock being used this morning. Not constant.. Only seen it once. Just the BBC News standard 'wipe' as used on the main news when plugging the twitter accounts of Nick Robinson etc. but an orange bar not white. It loops through Contact us / bbcbreakfast@bbc.co.uk / @bbcbreakfast / #bbcbreakfast / Contact Us / ....... It also moves up on top of the name aston if it hasn't gone through the loops.

Anyone got any screen grabs of this because I cant' seem to find it at all on the iPlayer restart?

41 days later

HB
HarryB
The presenting schedule has been posted for this Christmas

Sat 20/12/14 – Jon Kay & Naga Munchetty
Sun 21/12/14 – Christian Fraser & Sian Lloyd
Mon 22/12/14 – Bill Turnbull & Louise Minchin
Tues 23/12/14 – Bill Turnbull & Louise Minchin
Christmas Eve – Bill Turnbull & Louise Minchin
Christmas Day – Bill Turnbull
Boxing Day – Sally Nugent
Sat 27/12/14 – Jon Kay & Naga Munchetty
Sun 28/12/14 – Jon Kay & Naga Munchetty
Mon 29/12/14 – Bill Turnbull & Naga Munchetty
Tues 30/12/14 – Bill Turnbull & Naga Munchetty
New Years Eve - Bill Turnbull & Naga Munchetty
New Years Day – Charlie Stayt
Fri 02/01/15 – Charlie Stayt & Steph McGovern

Mod Edit: User was banned for 1 week because of this post. We've said dull rota talk (that's just lists with no added content of value) are not permitted. Bail
AS
ASO
Thank you ever so much. I will treasure that information.
SK
Skygeek
The presenting schedule has been posted for this Christmas

Sat 20/12/14 – Jon Kay & Naga Munchetty
Sun 21/12/14 – Christian Fraser & Sian Lloyd
Mon 22/12/14 – Bill Turnbull & Louise Minchin
Tues 23/12/14 – Bill Turnbull & Louise Minchin
Christmas Eve – Bill Turnbull & Louise Minchin
Christmas Day – Bill Turnbull
Boxing Day – Sally Nugent
Sat 27/12/14 – Jon Kay & Naga Munchetty
Sun 28/12/14 – Jon Kay & Naga Munchetty
Mon 29/12/14 – Bill Turnbull & Naga Munchetty
Tues 30/12/14 – Bill Turnbull & Naga Munchetty
New Years Eve - Bill Turnbull & Naga Munchetty
New Years Day – Charlie Stayt
Fri 02/01/15 – Charlie Stayt & Steph McGovern

The people ON this list will be paying less-close attention to it than certain parties who post such things.
sda|, bazinga and rob gave kudos
BR
Brekkie
It's questionable whether it's worth firing up the Breakfast studio on Sunday mornings as it is, but don't really see the point on Christmas Day. Indeed isn't Breakfast on Christmas morning quite a recent development - used to be a news bulletin (at most) then CBBC.

Newer posts