« Topics
1234...515253
the eye3,536 posts since 19 Jan 2005
BBC World
That is the type of graphic someone would have posted in the mock section and been criticised to death for, based on how simple and lacking in anything it is. Why can’t we critique broadcast graphics in the same way?

Heck I made this 12 years ago... that background loop could well be that old too. (Made it in Sony Vegas 6 😂)
d
3
Brekkie, tweedledum and Mike W gave kudos
Mike W4,862 posts since 30 Apr 2006
London London
Bit unfair to be judging the quality of the work, based on a badly compressed Twitter video.

I have to agree with the eye on this one, it's nice but it's not stunning or amazing, it's an orange sphere with an orange fractal background, hardly groundbreaking. And there are plenty of old mocks of similar par to this actual design that would be shredded apart on here!
Oh it's such a perfect day, I'm glad I spent it with you...
1
Lou Scannon gave kudos
Moz5,333 posts since 4 Jan 2003
Wales Today
Bit unfair to be judging the quality of the work, based on a badly compressed Twitter video.

I have to agree with the eye on this one, it's nice but it's not stunning or amazing, it's an orange sphere with an orange fractal background, hardly groundbreaking. And there are plenty of old mocks of similar par to this actual design that would be shredded apart on here!


I think it’s nice, but where does it fit with the rest of the BBC News graphics? Where’s the cat’s cradle and place names?

The horizon was a bit of a stretch from the existing globe, but was at least tied to it a bit with the cat’s cradle, but this has lost all connection. It’s like Breakfast is once again totally separated from the main BBC News brand.

That said, it’s 100 times better than having the main BBC titles merged with a disco ball! It’s the morning, not a time for dancing! Things should be quieter and more subtle in the morning, not more jazzy. I can hardly open my eyes until 10am usually!
#skillsforlife
Jay Lee542 posts since 7 Apr 2015
London
A minor point but there was another "accidental" use of the Reith double box template on Breakfast earlier this morning when Will Perry was speaking to a boxing journalist in the US at around 8:40am.

Implementing Reith at BBC News has been ridiculously messy and erratic, though I appreciate it's considered to be a complex affair.
Brekkie31,169 posts since 4 Jan 2003
HTV Wales Wales Today
Implementing Reith at BBC News has been ridiculously messy and erratic, though I appreciate it's considered to be a complex affair.

It's been made an even more complex affair by the BBC and BBC News than it should have been.
I preferred the internet when it had a sense of humour.
2
Lou Scannon and Jay Lee gave kudos