The Newsroom

ASIA Disaster - Coverage & Discussion

150,000 Confirmed Dead (December 2004)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
JA
jay Founding member
cat posted:
jay posted:
cummig20 posted:
News room posted:
cat posted:
Just had a look at Fox News.

They have been talking about the plight of the Victoria's Secret model who was caught up in the events, not missing the opportunity to show some half-naked pictures of her at the same time, and reminding us how tragic it is that a woman of such delicacy and beauty should be caught up in all this.

Really does make me feel sick.


Yeah that's quite respulsive. Surely in an event such as this, everyone is equal, who the hell wants to know about whether people of celebrity status have been involved over say Joe Bloggs and his wife from Doncaster.


I agree. Last night I kept hearing about Lord Attenborough and how his granddaughter had died. Fair enough, it is a personal tragedy for the man and I feel sympathy for everyone who has lost family and friends in the tragedy, but I didn't think we needed to hear this as it makes no difference whether he is a well-known person or not, it doesn't make his loss any greater than anyone else's.


Whilst that is true, you could apply the same thing to the death of Princess Diana. Just because she was part of the royal family...

Lord Attenborough came from my village..my grandma has got pictures of her mum with him. It's a sad loss for him and for the whole country: they were not just members of his family, but British citezens.


Sorry, it's nothing like Princess Diana dying.

She died with 2 other people in a car crash... 60,000+ people dying in tsunamis is as different as it could possibly be.

In a situation like Princess Diana's death, it was logical to focus on her. When thousands upon thousands of people have died and millions of people have been made homeless, it is totally irrelevant to put 'ANGUISH OF ATTENBOROUGH' on the front pages.


Indeed, and I totally agree with you.
But out of the 20 or so Britons that died, Lord Attenborough was the logical focus.

And I was only using Diana as an extreme example, I'm sure there are many better examples out there but I couldn't think of one off the top of my head.
MO
Moz
cummig20 posted:
I can see why people want to have senior correspondents on the scene, but the South-East Asia Correspondents are also journalists, and it is their job to cover news from that region. Why send out people from London to cover a story that can be done just as well by the (roughly) 10 people that are already in the region?


...and it is these correspondents' jobs to cover that area. They know it far better than Ben Brown, Jeremy Thompson etc.

It would be slightly contrary to the News 24 advert with reporters who know '...the first minister, the groundsman at the Millennium Stadium...' and then sending in someone else to cover it!

Agreed that News 24 should have called in the main anchors though.
CU
cummig20
That's the point I was making and if I was one of those correspondents I'd get a little annoyed if the BBC sent someone else to do my job for me just because they are a better known face or have more experience etc. How would these people get more experience or become a well-known face on the BBC if whenever there is a chance for them to report from their base, someone else is sent to do it?
GJ
GJ05
UN say 80,000 could be dead

GJ
NR
News room
cummig20 posted:
That's the point I was making and if I was one of those correspondents I'd get a little annoyed if the BBC sent someone else to do my job for me just because they are a better known face or have more experience etc. How would these people get more experience or become a well-known face on the BBC if whenever there is a chance for them to report from their base, someone else is sent to do it?


Yeah but people like Ben Brown, Gavin Hewitt etc are given titles like Special Correspondent for this reason, so they can be deployed when stories such as these arise, because that's their job. Do you recall Arafat in Paris. The Paris bureau is already manned by Caroline Wyatt and Alan Little, yet Stephen Sackur and Jeremy Bowen were also sent. I am sure we'll see the heavy bods out there either today or tomorrow.
NR
News room
Does anyone know who wil present the BBC News Special this evening on ONE?? Presumably it'll be George Alagiah and someone from News 24????
MO
Moz
News room posted:
Does anyone know who wil present the BBC News Special this evening on ONE?? Presumably it'll be George Alagiah and someone from News 24????


So is it a simulcast on N24? If so is it from their studio or from the 1/6/10 studio?
NR
News room
Moz posted:
News room posted:
Does anyone know who wil present the BBC News Special this evening on ONE?? Presumably it'll be George Alagiah and someone from News 24????


So is it a simulcast on N24? If so is it from their studio or from the 1/6/10 studio?


It will be shown on both News 24 and One, not sure about World.
TE
TELEVISION
I think it must be quite difficult for George Alagiah to anchor the Tsunami coverage because he was born in Sri Lanka, and grew up there. He may not have lived near where this disaster took place, but it still must be quite upsetting, he will have family etc. back there.
BR
Brekkie
Well, today's lunchtime BBC bulletin was the first BBC News programme I'd seen since Sunday (I've quite deliberatly avoid the 24 hr news channels this time). It was sufficient, but just not quite right. One advantage ITV News have had is the use of images on the news wall - it has more of an impact than "Earthquake Disaster" in the bottom left corner.

They also plugged tonight's 7.30pm bulletin: "BBC News Special - The Great Wave". Maybe I'm being oversensitive, but the programme name sounds more like an attempt to break the Mexican waving world record than the biggest natural disaster in a generation.
NR
News room
The News Special has been plugged at every possible point since it was decided yesterday evening, both on One and on N24. It will be interesting to see what they come up with.

Here is the full press release from bbc.co.uk/pressoffice

There will be a special programme following Sunday's earthquake disaster at 7.30pm on BBC ONE tonight (Wednesday 29 December 2004).

BBC News Special: The Great Wave will be presented by Huw Edwards in London and Jeremy Bowen in Sri Lanka.

It will include BBC correspondents from across the disaster area. John Simpson will also be contributing.

The programme will be followed by the Disasters Emergencies Committee Tsunami Earthquake Appeal.

The special programme replaces the billed programme, Only Fools and Horses.

The Disasters Emergencies Committee Tsunami Earthquake Appeal will also be broadcast at 10.15pm on BBC TWO.

BBC News Special: The Great Wave will also be shown on BBC World today (Wednesday) at 1930 GMT.

ends...

It was only a matter of time before the BBC deployed their big wigs. Edwards, Bowen and Simpson, what more could you ask for.
AN
Ant
GJ05 posted:
UN say 80,000 could be dead

GJ

BBC News saying it is likely it will reach 100,000 Surprised . http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/4132725.stm

Newer posts