The Newsroom

Andrea Catherwood tipped to replace Trevor McDonald

(January 2005)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
DE
denton
BBC LDN posted:
DAS posted:
I am firmly of the belief that if you look at Trevor McDonald on paper, he is rubbish. Yet he is brilliant - I have no idea how or why, but that's a widely accepted fact. Same with Peter Sissons. He has character and presence. Andrea Catherwood does not.


Sir Trevor McDonald is spectacularly dull and massively overrated. He makes George Alagiah look exciting and animated.

And don't get me started on Peter Sissons. Character and presence are two things he is most assuredly lacking - unless you associate those two things with continual mis-reading of the autocue, pregnant pauses during interviews, blubbering and blustering about with his dreadful ad libs to hand over to Sport or Weather, and his complete and overwhelming inability to cope with breaking news.

I actually pray to God to hold off any world events likely to be mentioned as breaking news until after Sissons' shift is over, because listening to the man trying to tell you that something terrible or interesting has just happened is like watching an asthmatic turtle trying to run for a bus.


At last. Someone who I can agree with. Sir Trevor never seems to manage to pronounce the last letter of any word he speaks. George Alagiah usually manages to pause for breath in the wrong place in every sentence, giving the impression he doesn't understand what he is saying. And as for Peter Sissons, I agree with everything you've said.

While I'm not a fan of Andrea Catherwood, it would be nice to see one of ITN's fine Northern Irish people take over the top job. Wink
TE
TELEVISION
I personally think Nicholas Owen deserves the job, but I think he is quite happy on the Luchtime programme. I really would have put money on Mark Austin getting top job.
SO
southwales
Dermot has been approached so i HAVE HEARD
MI
Mikeroberts
It would not surprise me if Dermot had been approached, along with some of the other faces on the BBC, especially people like Darren Jordan or Jane Hill.
AN
Andrew Founding member
TELEVISION posted:
I personally think Nicholas Owen deserves the job, but I think he is quite happy on the Luchtime programme. I really would have put money on Mark Austin getting top job.

Mark Austin already has the top job. The late news stopped being ITV's flagship when News at Ten was axed first time round
WM
Weather Man
if Mark Austin comes on the air, we might as well all decide to do his "eyes up to haven cos Nina is talking", or pick up the sheets from the other side of the desk. i cant stand him as a presenter, he just isnt bothered.

i would like to possibly see Anglea Ripppon on NATT, but she is a bit too quiet.

another one is Alistair Stewart, he did present it at one stage (under NAT) but i think he could come back

out of all siad so far, Nicholas Owen would be a good presenter, with Katie Derham on the Lunchtime, she loves doing her cat walk thing at the end of the show. Just look at that one foot in front of the other motion, along with the hands straight down and the hips slowly moving!!
GS
Gavin Scott Founding member
Ooh I love Mark Austin.

He'll be pleased to know.
BR
Brekkie
Weather Man posted:
out of all siad so far, Nicholas Owen would be a good presenter, with Katie Derham on the Lunchtime, she loves doing her cat walk thing at the end of the show. Just look at that one foot in front of the other motion, along with the hands straight down and the hips slowly moving!!


Going wildly off topic, but have ITV News (probably the ITV News Channel) ever used their catwalk as a catwalk for some tedious link to a fashion story?
TE
TELEVISION
Andrew posted:
TELEVISION posted:
I personally think Nicholas Owen deserves the job, but I think he is quite happy on the Luchtime programme. I really would have put money on Mark Austin getting top job.

Mark Austin already has the top job. The late news stopped being ITV's flagship when News at Ten was axed first time round


I know what you mean, but ITV still see this as their ' flagship ' bulletin, even if the Evening News is more of a ' flagship '.
LO
LONDON
TELEVISION posted:
Andrew posted:
TELEVISION posted:
I personally think Nicholas Owen deserves the job, but I think he is quite happy on the Luchtime programme. I really would have put money on Mark Austin getting top job.

Mark Austin already has the top job. The late news stopped being ITV's flagship when News at Ten was axed first time round


I know what you mean, but ITV still see this as their ' flagship ' bulletin, even if the Evening News is more of a ' flagship '.


Yes the News at Ten thirty is the flagship bulletin. The Evening news was the flagship bulletin, when it was fronted by Trevor and before News at Ten was relaunched.
LO
Londoner
ITV Wales News's Lucy Owen is 20/1 to replace Sir Trevor... Laughing
LO
Londoner
The News at 10.30 may nominally be the flagship - mainly due to Sir Trev's presence - but it is clear that the Evening News is the best-resourced and most-watched weekday ITV News programme.

I seem to remember cat saying that the ITV Evening News is the climax of the ITV News operation whilst the 10.30 is rather post-coital. [Previously the News at Ten had been the high point of the daily news cycle for ITV News]. For some reason that analogy stuck in my mind.

Newer posts