The Newsroom

2007 - Newscaster of the Year

(December 2007)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
ST
STV Today
My votes for 2007:

National Presenter: HUW EDWARDS
>Huw remains a great anchorman as has not slipped or become robotic on a regular slot. He makes Trevor McDonald look like dated and stale.

Rolling News: ANNA BOTTING
>one of the few jewels of the clapped out European News Channel that is Sky News. She works well as a single anchorwoman who interviews properly and exudes gravitas and credibility.

Global: SHUILIE GHOSH
>missed on ITN but a great credible addition to Al Jazeera English.

Regional: CATRIONA SHEARER
>someone who I personally hope becomes the new Jackie Bird. A great communicator who does not seem aloof or over confident. Go Catriona Go Hen!!

Business: JULIETTE FOSTER
>I am delighted that BBC World has ensured Miss Foster does not fall in the scrap heap of Sky News leftovers. She is a great communicator who makes her subject appealing.

Most Improved Performer: SOPHIE RAWORTH
>I think she works well on her own and has ensured the One o'Clock News remains a top notch bulletin with gravitas. She has also not fell into the celebrity bandwagon that dogs her generation of newscasters.

Slipped a Little: FIONA BRUCE
>lost my vote of confidence by dressing like a prossie on Children In Need and I fear may be loosing her grip on the Ten bulletin. Emily Maitlis may nip in when she aint looking?

Hard as Nails: JON SNOW
>a tough cookie who has not lost his touch.

Best Newcomer: RANVIR SINGH
>a welcome addition to the BBC's regional offerings. I only wish my own region would give a younger female presenter such a big break in 2008.

Most Missed: ANNE MACKENZIE
>I now realise Anne is a freelancer and that she was inevitably one of the first victims of the BBC's downsizing. I only hope we do see her or hear her again - time will tell.

Best Newscast: BBC TEN O'CLOCK NEWS
>I am sure the relaunch of News of Ten is just an anti-climax. I am sure the BBC will reign supreme in the marathon.

Worst Newscasts: SKY NEWS (except when Anna Botting is on)
>this channel has hit the scrap heap and I cannot see it getting better in the new year. Anna B is one of the jewels though and I am just glad she seems in favour at the moment.

Best News Channel Overall: BBC
>while I was hacked off at their treatment of Moira, I still think they are miles ahead of any other channel.

Best Regional Programme: BBC NORTH WEST TONIGHT
>let's pray Reporting Scotland gets a new title sequence like this a good hybrid of new and old BBC opening sequences.

Overall 2007 Winner: MOIRA STUART
>she gets my vote because she left the BBC with dignity and did not head butt Helen Boaden or kick Mark Thompson in the balls. I hope that we do see Moira on the box soon though - perhaps on ITV or Five?
IT
itsrobert Founding member
National Presenter: ALASTAIR STEWART
Rolling News: NICHOLAS OWEN
Global: ADRIAN FINIGHAN
Biz: TANYA BECKETT
Most Improved Performer: JONATHAN CHARLES
Slipped a Little: MARK AUSTIN
Hard as Nails: JON SNOW
Best Partnership: SIMON MCCOY & CARRIE GRACIE
Worst Presenter: GERAINT VINCENT
Best Weather: DANIEL CORBETT

Best Newscast: ITV EVENING NEWS
Worst Newscast: BBC WORLD NEWS AMERICA
Best News Channel Overall: BBC WORLD

Overall 2007 Winner: ADRIAN FINIGHAN
Because: Still as excellent as the first time I saw him on BBC World. He seems to have settled into CNN very well and it's nice to see him out and about every once in a while. It shows that he has both studio and reporting skills.
FG
Funky Guy
Rolling : Alastair Yates.
National : Geraint Vincent (Sex on legs gorgeous )
Regional : Lucy Meacock.

Warmed alot to : Nina Hossain realy like her now .
Worst :Penny Smith.
Annoying :George Alagiya.

Ones i want to see back on TV .

Julia Sommerville.
Carol Barnes.
Frances Coverdale.
Leyla Debelge.
IT
itsrobert Founding member
Funky Guy posted:
Rolling : Alastair Yates.
National : Geraint Vincent (Sex on legs gorgeous )
Regional : Lucy Meacock.

Warmed alot to : Nina Hossain realy like her now .
Worst :Penny Smith.
Annoying :George Alagiya.

Ones i want to see back on TV .

Julia Sommerville.
Carol Barnes.
Frances Coverdale.
Leyla Debelge.


Yes, I agree with Julia Somerville and Carol Barnes. They are very much missed. It was also nice when Angela Rippon was on the ITV NC for a while. It's a shame they didn't keep her on after its closure. I'm glad they did keep Alastair Stewart on, though, and that he's become a permanent fixture.
ST
STV Today
Funky Guy posted:

National : Geraint Vincent (Sex on legs gorgeous )


Well done Funky Guy - you added a cracker of a category...

Sexiest: JOHN MACKAY on Scotland Today
>he is as smooth as 007 and I would be willing to see his lethal weapon as well phwoar!!!
FG
Funky Guy
Wink Your telling me i can't even listen to the news when he's on i just drool over him instead.I know this is very cheeky and off topic way off topic but since it is Xmas .What is the lowdown on Geraint Vincent any inside info .I'd love to know if he has a hairy chest . Embarassed
FG
Funky Guy
Anne MacKenzie Fan posted:
Funky Guy posted:

National : Geraint Vincent (Sex on legs gorgeous )


Well done Funky Guy - you added a cracker of a category...

Sexiest: JOHN MACKAY on Scotland Today
>he is as smooth as 007 and I would be willing to see his lethal weapon as well phwoar!!!


OMG Razz
JR
jrothwell97
Anne MacKenzie Fan posted:
Funky Guy posted:

National : Geraint Vincent (Sex on legs gorgeous )


Well done Funky Guy - you added a cracker of a category...

Sexiest: JOHN MACKAY on Scotland Today
>he is as smooth as 007 and I would be willing to see his lethal weapon as well phwoar!!!


I would desperately like to know how we got from talking about prestigious national awards to a local newsreader's genitals.
FG
Funky Guy
I think it's a case of the snowball effect i'm afraid.Xmas has come early. Very Happy
ST
STV Today
jrothwell97 posted:
Anne MacKenzie Fan posted:
Funky Guy posted:

National : Geraint Vincent (Sex on legs gorgeous )


Well done Funky Guy - you added a cracker of a category...

Sexiest: JOHN MACKAY on Scotland Today
>he is as smooth as 007 and I would be willing to see his lethal weapon as well phwoar!!!


I would desperately like to know how we got from talking about prestigious national awards to a local newsreader's genitals.


Scrooge lol - he is a regional newscaster btw

Another thing about John Mackay - he does have a sense of humour Razz
JR
jrothwell97
Anne MacKenzie Fan posted:
jrothwell97 posted:
Anne MacKenzie Fan posted:
Funky Guy posted:

National : Geraint Vincent (Sex on legs gorgeous )


Well done Funky Guy - you added a cracker of a category...

Sexiest: JOHN MACKAY on Scotland Today
>he is as smooth as 007 and I would be willing to see his lethal weapon as well phwoar!!!


I would desperately like to know how we got from talking about prestigious national awards to a local newsreader's genitals.


Scrooge lol - he is a regional newscaster btw

Another thing about John Mackay - he does have a sense of humour Razz


Bah humbug. The comment to which you replied was also humourous and sarcastic.
TO
Tom0
I've not filled them all in.

National Presenter: JON SNOW
I think he continues to deliver a firm, informative and authorative reports as well as not taking everything too seriously which are really good qualities to have.

Most Improved Performer: NINA HOSSAIN
At the start of the year, I loathed this woman. I thought she was a stuck up arrogant cow but now I think she is a top class news presenter

Slipped a Little: MARY NIGHTINGALE
She now sounds like she is about to break down into tears at any moment but she does give good bulletins

Hard as Nails: MARK AUSTEN
Although not the best newsreader in the world, he didn't go easy on Michael Grade despite being on the same channel. It was a good report to watch.

Best Partnership: JOHN STAPLETON AND KATE GARRAWAY
Not a parnership we usually see as we usually see Penny on the Newshour but at the times when Kate is on the Newshour, they both deliver a good show with a good mixture of hard hitting news and fluffy items and they work well together.

Worst Presenter: FIONA PHILLIPS OR NATASHA KAPLINSKY
First vote goes to Fiona Phillips but if GMTV Today doesn't class as a news program, then by vote goes to Natasha.

Best Weather: JO BLYTHE

Worst Newscast: CBS NEWS ON SKY NEWS
It shows laziness from Sky News' schedulers

Best News Channel Overall: CHANNEL 4

Worst Dressed: KATIE DERHAM Laughing

Overall 2007 Winner: LUCY MEACOCK
Because: She is an excellent host, she isn't overdramatic and she has a good delivery. I hope there are more stints on the ITV Weekend News to come from Lucy in 2008.

Newer posts