« Topics
123
natwel27279 posts since 14 Mar 2019
Meridian (South East) South East Today
It's currently running the risk of resembling the current BBC Three logo. Idents and surrounding pres are truly fantastic I must say, however the logo almost seems far to imposing. I first thought maybe a horizontal line along the bottom connecting the three vertical lines, just to further push the fact that the logo represents a 'W', though that would most likely result in a plethora of subsequent issues.
TWL959 posts since 19 Aug 2019 new member
Granada Wales Today
To be honest I think I preferred what you posted first time round, your revised "blocks" for want of a better term look like they're struggling to stand up.

I feel you might have limited traction with this logo while they remain slanted.


It's currently running the risk of resembling the current BBC Three logo. Idents and surrounding pres are truly fantastic I must say, however the logo almost seems far to imposing. I first thought maybe a horizontal line along the bottom connecting the three vertical lines, just to further push the fact that the logo represents a 'W', though that would most likely result in a plethora of subsequent issues.


so practically revert back to the old logo in order to stop trying to improve it incase more issues arise?
1
Rexogamer gave kudos
TWL959 posts since 19 Aug 2019 new member
Granada Wales Today
To be honest I think I preferred what you posted first time round, your revised "blocks" for want of a better term look like they're struggling to stand up.

I feel you might have limited traction with this logo while they remain slanted.


It's currently running the risk of resembling the current BBC Three logo. Idents and surrounding pres are truly fantastic I must say, however the logo almost seems far to imposing. I first thought maybe a horizontal line along the bottom connecting the three vertical lines, just to further push the fact that the logo represents a 'W', though that would most likely result in a plethora of subsequent issues.


so practically revert back to the old logo in order to stop trying to improve it incase more issues arise?


I'll take that as a yes
Brekkie32,294 posts since 4 Jan 2003
HTV Wales Wales Today
Still don't like it I'm afraid. Personally think it might be better flipped so it slanted the other way, but overall just think it doesn't work alongside the "BBC Wales" logo and it's also just too 2D.
I preferred the internet when it had a sense of humour.
Josh1,012 posts since 21 Dec 2014
Anglia (East) Look East
From a design perspective, I feel the idents represent Wales well (even though I'm not from Wales!) and work nicely. I can see the similarities to BBC Scotland and they both tie together nicely.

From a technical point of view, would there be a point in keeping BBC Two Wales running and having this as a "major timeslot", as you phrased it? As well as this, I don't think it would make sense to hand over to the NC as BBC Scotland doesn't do this and there would be some continuity between the channels if that were to happen. Same goes with the national anthem.

Other than that and the other points mentioned by my peers, keep it up as you've got a great mock! Smile
Fan of the media industry, from the UK.
TWL959 posts since 19 Aug 2019 new member
Granada Wales Today
From a design perspective, I feel the idents represent Wales well (even though I'm not from Wales!) and work nicely. I can see the similarities to BBC Scotland and they both tie together nicely.

From a technical point of view, would there be a point in keeping BBC Two Wales running and having this as a "major timeslot", as you phrased it? As well as this, I don't think it would make sense to hand over to the NC as BBC Scotland doesn't do this and there would be some continuity between the channels if that were to happen. Same goes with the national anthem.

Other than that and the other points mentioned by my peers, keep it up as you've got a great mock! Smile


thanks Josh