The Gallery

ITV

ITV Network New look (October 2011)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
CR
Critique
Jonny posted:
So, you thought the best way to counteract criticism would be to completely ignore it and unleash **** mock armageddon?

Quite hard to believe that you're still getting a kick out of this.


Exactly what I was going to say. You used to boast that you took comments on board and changed to see fit, but this time you've just started churning out absolute rubbish, despite cries of 'STOP, MY EYES ARE BURNING'...
JO
Jonny
Look, if you don't like my mocks then stop looking at them, other people may like to see what I think would look good on ITV so if you got no good feedback just STOP commenting please

No they don't. They really, really don't.

Case in point, your latest videos: the ITV1 logo is wrong. Badly wrong. You know this to be the case yet posted it anyway.

Start listening to criticism or stop clogging up the board with pointless tat, because until you learn to do the former, you can not expect anything constructive in return.

Except this post, of course.
MA
Malpass
here are 2 new videos

V1

V2

which one is better?


That's vile. You'll be receiving a court summons real soon, I want damages for distress caused. That looks like you detonated some kind of bomb and used the putrid yellow smoke as a backdrop.

Urgh...
DO
dosxuk
other people may like to see what I think would look good on ITV


You really think that would look good on ITV?! Shocked

Here's some "good feedback" for you (avoids pun involving high pitched noises):

here are 2 new videos

which one is better?


Which one do you think is better? Why? What made you make the changes you did, and what are you trying to achieve? Why haven't you used the correct ITV logo? Why have you ignored the 4:3 safe areas? How does this relate to your earlier mocks in this thread?

Technical ability means nothing when the ideas are crap. And at the moment, you're not explaining your ideas at all, leaving only your technical inability. There have been good mocks done in paint and even on paper posted to this site in the past, there have also been very bad ones done in expensive professional software, and this has more in common with the latter.

Final tip - don't want bad feedback? Don't post something you've only been working on for 30 minutes after school.
MW
Mike W
Ever get the feeling somebody's sent him the ITV font so he tries to rub it in our faces by jizzing out as many mocks as possible using it...

For the record; It's crap. You've spent NO time working on planning this at all, just slapped it all together in powerpoint and saved it as a WMV....
SR
SomeRandomStuff
Ever get the feeling somebody's sent him the ITV font so he tries to rub it in our faces by jizzing out as many mocks as possible using it...

For the record; It's crap. You've spent NO time working on planning this at all, just slapped it all together in powerpoint and saved it as a WMV....


He's got the correct font alright just a shame he hasn't used it properly. He's used the correct logo in some of his earlier stuff, yet these most recent ones have a hack job logo.

He's got some pretty decent video editing software that can do visual effects, probably better than we've seen in his mocks. What i dont understand is; how can someone with all those resources at their disposal still come up with the crap that we've seen.

The newest piece of graphics software I have is an 8 year old copy of Adobe Illustrator CS1 and iMovie 2011 (which i really dont know how to use properly since they changed everything round) and I don't think I'm being presumptuous in saying that my stuff is miles better than his, and i've got loads of crap on my computer that i'd never submit to this forum...

TIME... take some of it... instead of churning out rubbish every week that's obviously had no time spent on it, and no attention has been paid to detail. Compare it to what you see on the TV... if your product is not approaching the quality of what you would see on TV, then don't post it.

I'm sure your mocks will improve in future, but until they do, you're going to keep getting ONE star... which means AWEFUL, in case you hadnt hothered to bover the cursor over it.

PS. You cant criticise the people on here for criticising your mocks... when you put it here to be criticised in the first place. If you posted your mocks on this forum to just get praise, you've come to the wrong place.

To paraphrase Captain Kirk... "Gentlemen, I don't want to interrupt this mutual admiration society, but I'd like to know where the good mocks are."
MA
Malpass
That isn't the right font anyway, is it?
JB
JasonB
deleted.
Last edited by JasonB on 20 October 2011 9:11pm
DB
dbl
That isn't the right font anyway, is it?


Correct
MW
Mike W
dbl posted:
That isn't the right font anyway, is it?


Correct


Well quite, just proves how much attention I was paying to these disgusting videos!
VG
Vgone
It's not up to forum standard, but it's better than the powerpoint mocks of a local weather station:

No offence S052970057, wherever on the forum you're lurking, but that mock sucked.
ID
Identity
2 new designs:

*


*

There isnt much difference with these to the pachage they use now its just they're a bit brighter

Newer posts