The Gallery

Good Morning Britain: Election 2015

Recreation/Improvement of the Election graphics (July 2015)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
DT
DTV
God this is tedious now. Aaron_2015 clearly only wants feedback that fits his view of the mock. None of the comments on here are inexcusable, all are perfectly valid comments. The difference between Lee's mock and yours is the time, effort, ideas, realisation, design and quality.

Time and effort: Judging by the fact that Critique was able to whip up the same mock in minutes does suggest that time and effort aren't really in play her.
Ideas: Your idea is the GMB graphics recreated with one thing essentially changed - the ITV seat ticker which was located there to ensure continuity between the ITV and GMB coverage.
Realisation/Quality: Quite frankly this could be done in PowerPoint with the same aesthetic quality.
Design: Most of the design was someone elses and you named this an improvement of which it isn't. The one feature that you have changed was put there intentionally by the original designers - either design a new package or don't change it.

No doubt this post is totally inexcusable for pointing out your own hypocrisies and bad manners. If you want feedback then take it, many have already given you similar feedback.
AA
Aaron_2015
Look, I accept that this isn't great. I have already said that. However, it is a realistic recreation. The improvement, however, is of course debatable. Unless anyone else has any feedback, I would rather just leave it now. I wish I had never posted any of it to be honest. A newer member is not going to make any difference to the long standing members. Thank you to everyone who did provide feedback, I read through all of the useful comments at least twice before creating the second version.
BB
BruceBBC
Look, everyone on the forum is just trying to be honest with you. All you've really done here is add a few coloured boxes to the current graphics.

I seen you've been a member since March, and since then you've already posted 9 mocks here in the Gallery. 5 of which have been of Good Morning Britain!!

Look, when you create a mock, leave it for a few days and then go back to it, see if there's anything you don't like it and would change. 9/10 this happens. Once you've done that, leave it again and go back the next day or whatever and check it again. Keep doing this until you are 100% satisfied!

If I'm being completely honest, I don't really see the point in this thread. Sorry.

I know you (as you put it) try your best but sometimes you just have to take some time. You keep pushing out mocks left, right and centre and it's becoming a wee bit daft tbh. You really need to focus on one specific mock and spend time on JUST that one. It's quite clear you've been busy with these graphics for this GMB mock, graphics for the Weekend mock and the studio for the weekend mock.
Don't jump from mock to the other, stick to one and put all your effort into that one!

Main point I'm trying to raise here is, SLOW DOWN WITH THE MOCKS AND TAKE YOUR TIME!

The gallery can be a tough place to crack.
Last edited by BruceBBC on 21 July 2015 2:12am
Justin, Multi and PATV Scunthorpe gave kudos

Newer posts