No VHS footage would be that bad unless the machine was knackered. I don't think it needed to be so wobbly and distorted to give it the VHS effect to be honest.
Fair point. I think I may have overdone the line sync a bit in Vegas.
Also, I think the positioning of the 2 on the slides could be more in to the corners, and it doesn't need the channel name and region identifier under it either. They didn't have that in the 90's, so it doesn't need to be in them now.
While I agree about the positioning of the 2, I don't quite agree with the statement about the channel name and region identifier. In 1991, when the old, slanted BBC logo was in use, it was positioned underneath the 2 in both the trails and the idents. I was attempting to replicate that in the mock.
Very lovely work. I think the only issue is the size of the BBC & especially 'Northern Ireland' under the logo. Other than that a very nice recreation/update.
I do agree that the logo is quite small in the trails and slides but do bare in mind, that the logo would be more legible in 576p or even 480p.