BBC TV Rebrand Project

Well, I don't know when I will be able to continue with this mock. My computer crashed and I suspect it is the hard drive. I currently have the computer off and I will try to recover the files by sticking the HD in another computer.

Thanks for the positive comments everyone! I will change the BBC One colour when I either
Install Photoshop on another computer and recover the mock files
Leave the computer off for half an hour and see if my tablet works
or
Install Photoshop and starting from scratch.

I am currently typing this on my tablet and I hope to resume soon.

I'm very sorry to hear that.
I would hope the rating improves in that time, since it deserves 3 stars, not 2.

These make no sense.

It does, what's wrong with that?

Well the bottom two logos contradict the guidelines for a start.

I see the problem with Arts, the A should be almost level with the B of the BBC. I cannot see the main problem with why the News one doesn't fit in the guidelines.

Only possibility is that the size of the fonts does not match those of the first two, is that what you're saying?

The second two are clearly not the same font size as the first two.

It suffers from the same thing as FrancisTaylor's did yesterday "I've got a box this big, I must fit the smallest logo to that size, and then stretch and scale bits of the other logos to make them fit to the exact same size".

Just compare the logos when overlayed, or side by side...
http://home.vis-is.co.uk/data/mocks/ATTVP_BBC.jpg

I like how the "There must be a gap this big" lines are different on each image too

Is this how the BBC Knowledge logo would end up?
http://home.vis-is.co.uk/data/mocks/ATTVP_BBCKnowledge.jpg

So the 2 problems are found, but can be amended easily once he returns from fixing his computer etc..

I must say though, It is difficult to get positioning right sometimes, even using Paint or PowerPoint, it can be a struggle.

Maybe you, dosxuk, should have a go at this. Your Knowledge mock looks good.

I wouldn't call it a mock. It takes less than 2 minutes to make from scratch.

I see, it is easy. But I would like to see more efforts like that.

Just because it's simple to make doesn't automatically make it awful. For what it's worth what you made looks nice.

I agree with FrancisTaylor as (and this is a bad example) if you spend an hour in paint making something like this, does it make it awful?