LY
Those are some really good examples of giving the 1 more character. The regular version could work as a generic/news ident.
I think people have done this concept before but you've definitely done it a bit better. I still think there are issues - the Three logo is probably best left as it is, and I'm not sure about Four either, but the Scotland logo is near-perfect. I've warmed to One because of the videos you've done showing how it would look on screen, Two is just fine but it works great with the Curve idents, and I like the menu.
The only thing that comes to mind is in the first picture - could the BBC logos be colour coordinated with the channel logos? That might look better than the contrast of the black with each channel's different colour.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YuAMHAb55UE
I tried giving the 1 a bit of character. These are my results.
I tried giving the 1 a bit of character. These are my results.
Those are some really good examples of giving the 1 more character. The regular version could work as a generic/news ident.
I think people have done this concept before but you've definitely done it a bit better. I still think there are issues - the Three logo is probably best left as it is, and I'm not sure about Four either, but the Scotland logo is near-perfect. I've warmed to One because of the videos you've done showing how it would look on screen, Two is just fine but it works great with the Curve idents, and I like the menu.
The only thing that comes to mind is in the first picture - could the BBC logos be colour coordinated with the channel logos? That might look better than the contrast of the black with each channel's different colour.