BR
http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/digitaltv/a122759/itv-c4-submit-freeview-hd-plans.html
Previously....
OFCOM announce plans to reconfigure the BBC's second Freeview mux for HD, moving the current BBC streams, along with Five and S4C, to the BBC's other mux and the already packed ITV/C4 mux.
The broadcaster object, saying extra muxes are required for HD - and then for some unknown reason backdown and back OFCOM's plans.
BBC automatically get a HD slot, with other companies having to bid for the next two. A fourth will be made available later.
Unsurprisingly ITV and C4 have made bids - and unsurprisingly it highlights what a waste of space OFCOM's plan is. ITV's bid is to run a service daily from 6-11pm, which would include sport outside these hours and provision for other companies to use their space. A single service will operate in England and Wales, with local versions for Scotland and NI.
C4's bid is to air 4HD, a 24-hr simulcast of C4, in England, Scotland and NI, with S4C HD airing in Wales. Teletext is included as part of the plans. C4 also state Freeview HD boxes should be made with ethernet connections and built in PVRs to make it competitive in the VOD market.
I've stated my views on this before but these bids show how pointless the plan really is - you gain so little yet potentially lose so much, most notably the quality of the SD services. Rather than using DSO to improve the reception issues and picture quality, this plan will instead see extra channels squeezed into just two PSB muxes on order to provide this HD mux.
A five-hour service from ITV doesn't seem worth it, while the BBC are already beginning to outgrow their one HD channel. C4's may be a 24-hour stream, but is far from a 24-hour HD channel - and I don't think there really is a demand for S4C HD. It's bringing back a problem that DTT was supposed to solve.
As I've said before, Freesat should be pushed as the option for FTA HD programming. With the exception of a minority who don't like satellite dishes, whether they have a dish or not doesn't really affect most of those wanting HD TV - and once the cost of a HD TV is considered, the slightly extra cost of installing Freesat isn't really an issue.
Previously....
OFCOM announce plans to reconfigure the BBC's second Freeview mux for HD, moving the current BBC streams, along with Five and S4C, to the BBC's other mux and the already packed ITV/C4 mux.
The broadcaster object, saying extra muxes are required for HD - and then for some unknown reason backdown and back OFCOM's plans.
BBC automatically get a HD slot, with other companies having to bid for the next two. A fourth will be made available later.
Unsurprisingly ITV and C4 have made bids - and unsurprisingly it highlights what a waste of space OFCOM's plan is. ITV's bid is to run a service daily from 6-11pm, which would include sport outside these hours and provision for other companies to use their space. A single service will operate in England and Wales, with local versions for Scotland and NI.
C4's bid is to air 4HD, a 24-hr simulcast of C4, in England, Scotland and NI, with S4C HD airing in Wales. Teletext is included as part of the plans. C4 also state Freeview HD boxes should be made with ethernet connections and built in PVRs to make it competitive in the VOD market.
I've stated my views on this before but these bids show how pointless the plan really is - you gain so little yet potentially lose so much, most notably the quality of the SD services. Rather than using DSO to improve the reception issues and picture quality, this plan will instead see extra channels squeezed into just two PSB muxes on order to provide this HD mux.
A five-hour service from ITV doesn't seem worth it, while the BBC are already beginning to outgrow their one HD channel. C4's may be a 24-hour stream, but is far from a 24-hour HD channel - and I don't think there really is a demand for S4C HD. It's bringing back a problem that DTT was supposed to solve.
As I've said before, Freesat should be pushed as the option for FTA HD programming. With the exception of a minority who don't like satellite dishes, whether they have a dish or not doesn't really affect most of those wanting HD TV - and once the cost of a HD TV is considered, the slightly extra cost of installing Freesat isn't really an issue.