The Newsroom

The New ITV & BBC Weather Thread

BBC Thunderbolts - Are they Red, White or Blue... or yellow?

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
AN
Andrew Founding member
I assume Julian was on hand back in Belfast to actually do the weather... from the autocue whilst stood dead still
ST
South Today
I assume Julian was on hand back in Belfast to actually do the weather... from the autocue whilst stood dead still


Rita actually Razz

10 days later

WA
watchingtv


JT
jolly turnip
My favourite forecaster. His informed clear delivery will be missed.
RS
RichSwitch
Sorry to see Phil Avery’s left. For me, one of the better forecasters and he’ll be missed.

The worst forecasters IMO are Darren Bett (always seems like he’d rather be elsewhere), Louise Lear (patronising delivery, bit like a Playschool presenter), Nick Miller (delivery like a military briefing), Simon King (another like Darren Bett), Matt Taylor (just can’t get on with his voice), Helen Willetts. I don’t doubt their ability to forecast or interpret a forecast; it’s their presenting.

The best BBC forecasters IMO are Ben Rich, Chris Fawkes, and Tomasz Schafernaker (not much in it), Alina Jenkins and Stav Danaos, Carol Kirkwood and Susan Powell.

The worst thing is the new graphics package which has been disastrous, how small the UK appears, the dark blue background to the text, the loss of lightning on precipitation screens, etc etc. I’m sure it’s well documented. Since switching to MeteoGroup I’ve noticed presenters have less confidence in the forecasts than with the Met Office (especially long range but also from hour to hour when the situation is fluid/developing quickly).

To be fair, Tony Hall has a lot to answer for about the BBC as a whole, the BBC needs a serious change.
AN
all new Phil
Sorry to see Phil Avery’s left. For me, one of the better forecasters and he’ll be missed.

The worst forecasters IMO are Darren Bett (always seems like he’d rather be elsewhere), Louise Lear (patronising delivery, bit like a Playschool presenter), Nick Miller (delivery like a military briefing), Simon King (another like Darren Bett), Matt Taylor (just can’t get on with his voice), Helen Willetts. I don’t doubt their ability to forecast or interpret a forecast; it’s their presenting.

The best BBC forecasters IMO are Ben Rich, Chris Fawkes, and Tomasz Schafernaker (not much in it), Alina Jenkins and Stav Danaos, Carol Kirkwood and Susan Powell.

The worst thing is the new graphics package which has been disastrous, how small the UK appears, the dark blue background to the text, the loss of lightning on precipitation screens, etc etc. I’m sure it’s well documented. Since switching to MeteoGroup I’ve noticed presenters have less confidence in the forecasts than with the Met Office (especially long range but also from hour to hour when the situation is fluid/developing quickly).

To be fair, Tony Hall has a lot to answer for about the BBC as a whole, the BBC needs a serious change.

Remind me to publicly criticise the way that you speak whilst doing your job sometime. Jeez.
fusionlad and London Lite gave kudos
:-(
A former member
The member requested removal of this post
Last edited by A former member on 27 March 2021 1:47am
SuperSajuuk and DE88 gave kudos
MC
mccanmat
I’m surprised no one has mentioned the poor microphone on Darren Betts forecast after ten o clock news last night
MA
Markymark
I’m surprised no one has mentioned the poor microphone on Darren Betts forecast after ten o clock news last night


It was crap, and the CA surely could have slipped in a quick apology before launching into the lottery results
JJ
Juicy Joe Founding member
I can't believe there still haven't been any tweaks to the BBC Weather graphics 5 months after they were introduced. We still have "Birmingham" obliterating the map and the map is way too small. As well as all the other things that are wrong.
JJ
Juicy Joe Founding member
I really haven't been informed fully about the weather since the graphics were launched and every day is a complete mystery to me. You get a better idea by using the BBC Weather app and even that isn't ideal.
SS
SuperSajuuk
I didn’t even realise Phil Avery had left until i saw this thread. What a shame, he was an excellent presenter, great at making one liner jokes and he worked well with Simon when on Afternoon Live. He’ll be missed!

Newer posts